|
-
|
-
|
- Maryland /
Regional
-
More people
homeless in Baltimore
(Baltimore Sun)
-
Homeless shelter loses United Way funding
(Baltimore Sun)
-
Today, multiple answers to the familiar question: Got milk?
(Baltimore Sun)
-
Exercise
can reduce scoliosis symptoms
(Baltimore Sun)
-
MARYLAND Lawmakers request $30M for emergency preparedness
(Salisbury
Daily Times)
-
Funds
Sought for Preparedness Partnership
(Washington Post)
-
State, county officials take the heat at Ridgely Middle
(Catonsville
Times)
-
Maryland Department of Environment issues 80 enforcement
actions
(Baltimore Business Journal)
-
Alternative medicine meets mainstream hospitals
(USA Today)
-
- National /
International
-
House Democrats to consider taxing health benefits
(Baltimore Sun)
-
Exercising
for back pain relief
(Baltimore Sun)
-
Body of lies: Patients aren't 100% honest with doctors
(Baltimore Sun)
-
How to treat a sunburn
(Baltimore Sun)
-
Peanuts, Anyone?
(Washington Post)
-
Coming
Clean About Risk of Finger Food
(Washington Post)
-
Decision Makers Differ on How To Mend Broken Health System
(Washington
Post)
-
What to
know before buying supplements
(Washington Post)
-
At Last, Facing Down Bullies (and Their Enablers)
(New York Times)
-
Tests show many supplements have quality problems
(Washington Post)
-
Roche
Makes Headway on New Diabetes Drug
(Wall Street Journal)
-
HIV rate among South African teens has dropped
(Washington Post)
-
Is This a
Pandemic? Define ‘Pandemic’
(Washington Post)
-
Navy reports 21 swine flu cases on USS Iwo Jima
(Salisbury Daily Times)
-
Egypt: Five more Americans test positive for swine flu
(USA Today)
-
WHO may soon raise swine flu alert to pandemic level
(USA Today)
-
- Opinion
- ---
-
-
- Maryland /
Regional
-
More people
homeless in Baltimore
- Census shows 12% increase, underscores mayor's goal of
getting people off streets
-
- By Julie Bykowicz
- Baltimore Sun
- Tuesday, June 9, 2009
-
- Baltimore's homeless population is on the rise, a study
released Monday shows, bolstering Mayor Sheila Dixon's case
for spending millions on year-round emergency shelters and
the construction of a proposed permanent facility.
-
- The census, conducted Jan. 22, found 3,419 homeless
people, including those who live in shelters as well as more
than 1,000 street dwellers.
-
- The total was up 12 percent from two years ago, and
nearly 28 percent since the census began in 2003. The U.S.
Department of Housing and Urban Development requires the
biannual survey for federal funding.
-
- Early last year, Dixon announced a 10-year plan to end
homelessness in Baltimore. A 275-bed, $8.2 million emergency
facility on the Fallsway could open next spring, though the
city is still reviewing proposals. Dixon has also used
federal low-income housing vouchers to move about 150
homeless families and individuals into permanent residences
over the past 18 months.
-
- Diane Glauber, director of Baltimore Homeless Services,
said the census provides a rare snapshot of homelessness and
helps to show where to deploy resources for maximum impact.
Federal officials use the figures for some formula-based
grants, including money for emergency shelters.
-
- Some of the key findings this year include:
-
- •About 85 percent of the overall homeless population was
African-American.
-
- •About 23 percent of the 2,265 shelter occupants were
children.
-
- •Most of the street dwellers were men, and nearly half
of them were between ages 45 and 60.
-
- •More than 30 percent of the people in shelters were
chronically homeless with substance abuse and mental health
problems.
-
- Reaching out to the street population has proven
difficult for those trying to assist them.
-
- On a recent afternoon, Achike Oranye, an outreach worker
with People Encouraging People, and Gregory Sileo, the
city's homeless outreach coordinator, walked through
downtown to talk to some of the people who have been living
on the streets for years.
-
- Oranye and Sileo approached a pair of men at the mouth
of a dingy alley on Baltimore Street. The two showed the
effects of the alcohol they said they had been drinking all
afternoon. A 57-year-old in a wheelchair, who has been
homeless in the area for as long as anyone can remember (he
says 35 years), said drinking is his way of coping.
-
- Asked why he hadn't taken the city's offers of help, he
said, "I'm a survivor," and turned away. Sileo was visibly
frustrated.
-
- "At some point, it's like, 'What more can we do?' "
Sileo said. "We keep trying every day and hoping eventually
there will be a breakthrough."
-
- Baltimore's unsheltered homeless population ballooned
from 242 in 2005 to 1,154 this year, according to the
census, but officials attribute much of that increase to
better counting methods. About 75 volunteers flooded the
downtown area for the street count this year, compared to
fewer than a dozen in 2005.
-
- "The complexity of counting the homeless is a real
challenge," said Mary Anne Akers, dean of Morgan State
University's School of Architecture and Planning, which
tallied the numbers. "I don't think any city can say it is
100 percent accurate, but we are as close as we can be."
-
- National experts say undercounting is a problem with
almost any homeless population census. And every city counts
differently, making comparisons difficult.
-
- Philadelphia, which has about twice as many residents as
Baltimore, reports a shelter population of about 2,600 and a
street population of about 550. Washington, a slightly
smaller city, counted more than 6,000 homeless people,
including 378 on the streets, last year.
-
- Locally, Baltimore County also saw an increase in its
latest homeless census, counting 692 this year. Mary Harvey,
director of the Office of Community Conservation, said
better methodology accounts for some, but not all, of the
rise.
-
- Dixon said the city's census numbers came as no
surprise, given the national economic downturn and scant
resources for people with mental illness and substance
abuse.
-
- Baltimore is to receive about $10 million in federal
stimulus money to move homeless people into permanent
housing and to prevent homelessness by addressing
foreclosures.
-
- This winter, the Harry and Jeannette Weinberg Foundation
pledged $1.8 million to the proposed emergency shelter at
620 Fallsway.
-
- Dixon said she has been particularly focused on moving
chronically homeless street-dwellers into permanent housing.
Many of the housing vouchers for the homeless have gone to
people living in encampments under the Jones Falls
Expressway and on the grounds of St. Vincent de Paul Church
at the end of the expressway.
-
- While the emergency facility is being built, Dixon has
kept shelters open 24 hours a day throughout the year,
parting with the city's tradition of "code blue" shelters
open on only the most frigid of winter nights. Single men
and women stay at the former Health Department building on
Guilford Avenue - which battled a flea infestation a month
ago - and women with children stay at a facility on Mount
Street.
-
- "You definitely see less people on the streets because
of the shelters," Dixon said. "But they're still out there."
-
- The mayor says she frequently alerts Glauber and Sileo
to homeless people she sees on the streets day after day.
-
- Just two blocks from City Hall, Richard Crews, 54, has
been sitting in a blue camping chair, jangling a change cup,
for more than three years.
-
- Crews has received a federal housing voucher from
Dixon's homeless workers and been approved for a place on
Washington Boulevard, the outreach workers said. Yet Crews
hasn't left his spot.
-
- Oranye, a licensed counselor who has worked in Baltimore
for more than five years, said some of the veteran street
dwellers are loath to leave their downtown perches - places
that have become comfortable to them.
-
- Copyright 2009 Baltimore Sun.
-
-
Homeless shelter loses United Way funding
- Agency blames faulty funds application
-
- By Larry Carson
- Baltimore Sun
- Monday, June 8, 2009
-
- At a time when charitable giving is down because of the
national recession, United Way of Central Maryland will stop
funding for Howard County's main homeless shelter for the
first time since 1978.
-
- The action threatens to renew a 2007 rift over United
Way funding cuts to groups across the region. During that
dispute, Howard County Executive Ken Ulman threatened to
create a rival charitable organization or end county
government participation in United Way, but the dispute
ended with an agreement to allow more local influence over
the regional agency's funding grants.
-
- Despite that, Howard's Grassroots Crisis Intervention
Center was denied any money for the fiscal year starting
July 1. Grassroots, which last spring opened an enlarged,
$5.5 million homeless shelter in Columbia, had applied for
$77,950 to help fund its $2.4 million annual budget.
-
- By contrast, United Way doubled its contribution to
$61,000 for Congregations Concerned for the Homeless,
another Howard-based group, to provide transitional housing
for eight families. Howard-based Domestic Violence Center is
to get $25,000, the same amount as this year.
-
- The reason for halting funding for Grassroots is
unclear, with different accounts coming from the two sides.
-
- Andrea Ingram, Grassroots' executive director, said she
had no advance inkling of what was coming and is mystified
by the denial.
-
- "With our new facility, we've experienced an explosion
of need," she said. "This is huge for us," she said about
the loss of United Way support. Grassroots has had a
committee working since January to identify new sources of
money to combat funding problems, Ingram said. The United
Way money would have paid for two case managers to teach
financial literacy and to run emergency programs like the
new day center Grassroots opened along U.S. 1 last year to
provide showers, laundering services and food to a group of
chronically homeless people in North Laurel.
-
- "Our opinion is that they should have gotten this
funding," said Susan Rosenbaum, who as director of the
county's Department of Citizen Services reviewed Grassroots'
application. "We don't understand this decision."
-
- Ulman said he was "very disappointed" and expressed that
to Larry E. Walton, a county resident who is president and
chief professional officer for United Way of Central
Maryland.
-
- "Grassroots is one of the few organizations we increased
funding to," Ulman said about the county's grants to
nonprofits. "Arguably, it's the most important nonprofit in
our county."
-
- Walton said United Way's donations are projected to drop
$3 million under the goal for fiscal 2010. In response, the
group shortened its normal 30-month budgeting period to one
year in hopes that conditions will improve. United Way
awarded $2.6 million for the next fiscal year to 40
organizations across Central Maryland, compared to $4.2
million annually over the past several years. He said United
Way had 120 applications for requests totaling $10 million.
-
- The lowered funding combined with heightened needs, he
said, forced the organization to concentrate on "basic
needs," and stop funding youth agencies that were
traditional recipients such as the Boy Scouts and Girl
Scouts of Maryland, Big Brother and Big Sisters of Maryland
and the Boys and Girls Clubs of Harford County.
-
- In a letter to Ulman, Walton said six agencies serving
Howard would get $291,000 in fiscal 2010, plus $1.3 million
more designated by donors to go to nonprofits that serve or
are in the county. United Way allows contributors to choose
specific destinations for their gifts.
-
- Walton said he was surprised, however, when he saw
Grassroots was missing from the list, but added that the
application was faulty, a statement Howard County and
Grassroots officials contend isn't true.
-
- "They took themselves out of the race before the race
even started," Walton said, by "applying for programs we
weren't funding." Walton said he hopes Grassroots can
qualify next year, but in the interim may be able to get
some money from a $31,000 discretionary fund available for
Howard organizations.
-
- "They're a good agency," he said.
-
- Sandy Monck, United Way's senior vice president for
community impact strategies, said "they may have followed
the instructions of the Request for Proposals" , but "did
not meet the review criteria" when volunteers evaluating all
the requests applied United Way's four standards; limited
funding, alignment with United Way's priorities,
demonstrated capacity to provide services and good ways to
measure performance and do budgeting. She refused to say
specifically why Grassroots failed to qualify, adding that
United Way officials will meet with Ingram and her staff
soon to explain further.
-
- Ingram said Grassroots also lost $6,500 in other grants,
though Howard County pitched in an extra $11,000 for fiscal
2010. The county provides about $1 million of Grassroots'
annual budget, she said.
-
- Ulman said the May 21 decision to deny funding to
Grassroots seems to reverse the progress made after the last
dispute.
-
- "I had felt we were working much better together," he
said.
-
- He said he asked Walton to look for other funding
sources for Grassroots, and offered a new warning.
-
- "If this is more than a one-time issue, we may have to
look at our relationship with United Way," he said.
-
- Copyright 2009 Baltimore Sun.
-
-
Today, multiple answers to the familiar question: Got milk?
-
- By Laura Vozzella
- Baltimore Sun
- Monday, June 8, 2009
-
- Patty Sullivan of Catonsville is stumped by the dairy
case. One kind of milk promises to make her children
smarter. Another claims to come from healthier cows. Unable
to sort all that out, she reaches for good old, conventional
Costco milk."I find it very confusing," said Sullivan, who
picks up five gallons a week for the Burtonsville preschool
she runs. "You need a research degree to find out the
differences. And is it really that much better for you?"
-
- Not long ago, consumers only had to ponder one thing
before hefting a gallon jug into the shopping cart: How much
fat did they want? Then, more than a decade ago, organic
started showing up in ordinary supermarkets.
-
- Today, the world of milk is even more rarefied - and
more confusing, because the milk trucks are moving more
quickly than the science. Researchers can't even agree if
milk "does a body good," much less which kind is best. While
consumers can have their pick of more milk varieties than
ever before, they also have more questions about a product
considered to be a cornerstone of childhood nutrition - one
that each American, on average, slurps down at a rate of 24
gallons a year.
-
- There's milk from grass-fed cows, said to be more
nutritious and better for the environment. Milk with added
omega-3 fatty acids, touted as boosting brain function.
Nonhomogenized milk that fans are willing to shake before
drinking - in glass bottles, no less - on the premise that
their bodies won't absorb as much fat if it hasn't been
blasted into tiny bits.
-
- Ultra-pasteurized. Low-pasteurized. And unpasteurized
"raw" milk, whose devotees are so convinced of its superior
health benefits that they'll travel from Maryland, where
sales are outlawed, to Pennsylvania, where it's legit.
-
- With soy, rice and almond milks suddenly mainstream
fare, the dairy case has become more crowded than a feedlot.
The grocer's got milk, all right, even in a troubled economy
that reportedly has milk sales slumping.
-
- None of it is cheap.
-
- While Sullivan spent about $2.25 a gallon for that
conventional milk at Costco, Wendy Johnson, a
special-education teacher from Hanover, pays more than twice
as much for organic. She shells out even more - about $14 a
gallon - for individual, juice box-like containers of
organic milk for when the family's on the go.
-
- Johnson figures organic is best for her 5-year-old
daughter, but she has some doubts, precisely because of
those handy little "shelf-stable" boxes that don't need
refrigeration.
-
- "If you can put it on the shelf, what's left in it?"
Johnson wonders.
-
- Not that Johnson can take it as a given that milk is
good for her daughter in the first place.
-
- Just last month in the American Journal of Clinical
Nutrition, Purdue University foods and nutrition professor
Connie Weaver wrote that milk is an important source of
calcium and other nutrients, improves bone health and
reduces the risk of stroke and some cancers. Research has
put to rest concerns that it might increase prostate cancer,
she noted. But in the same issue, University of North
Carolina nutrition scientist Amy Joy Lanou argued that milk
increases prostate and ovarian cancers. Her advice: Stay
away from the stuff.
-
- Even the experts who think milk is healthful don't agree
on much else.
-
- The National Dairy Council and other industry groups
contend that all milks are created equal. The U.S. Food and
Drug Administration agrees, finding "no significant
difference" between organic milk and what flows from cows
given synthetic growth hormones to boost production.
-
- "We wouldn't favor one type of milk over another," said
Michael Herndon, an FDA spokesman. Like the Dairy Council,
Herndon dismissed the various milk varieties as pure
"marketing."
-
- But food-safety and sustainable-farming advocates
maintain that organic milk is safer. Even if the synthetic
hormones, approved by the FDA in 1994, do not show up in
conventional milk, they say, they seem to raise the level of
other, naturally occurring hormones in the milk that could
pose problems for humans. They also contend that artificial
hormones are rough on the cows, causing more infections
that, in turn, lead to more antibiotic use on the farm.
-
- In any case, these advocates say, there are too many
unknowns.
-
- "I think there's a real void in the science," said Patty
Lovera, assistant director of Food and Water Watch, a
consumer group based in Washington. "That just wasn't where
the [agricultural research] focus was. It was how to be
bigger, how to get faster."
-
- There is one point of consensus: Cows that feed on grass
produce milk that's higher in omega-3 fatty acids, vitamin
E, beta-carotene and an antioxidant called conjugated
linoleic acid - all good stuff for the body.
-
- But there's no way, short of farm surveillance, for
consumers to know if Bessie is really munching much green.
-
- To make milk worthy of the U.S. Department of
Agriculture organic label, cows cannot be treated with
antibiotics or synthetic growth hormones. The animals must
be given feed produced without chemical fertilizers and
pesticides. And the cows must have "access to pasture."
-
- The pasture part is problematic because the government
has not spelled out what "access to pasture" means. As for
milk marketed as "grass-fed," the FDA has not defined the
term at all.
-
- On this point alone, Big Dairy and food activists find
common ground.
-
- "Grazing is the key," wrote Rusty Bishop, director of
the Center for Dairy Research at the University of Wisconsin
in Madison. "The problem is that the majority of organic
fluid milk on the market is from cows on pasture an average
of 60 partial days, and pasture grasses make up less than 5
percent of their dryweight feed intake."
-
- Bishop's research center bills itself as independent but
receives substantial funding from the milk industry. His
comments about grazing are part of a June 2007 study that
otherwise pooh-poohs the purported advantages of organic
milk.
-
- But his grazing gripe could have easily come out of the
mouth of John Peck, who hails from way on the other side of
the milk debate. The executive director of the Madison,
Wis.-based Family Farm Defenders worries about factory farms
co-opting the organic label and wants the government to
establish grazing standards.
-
- So while he agrees with Bishop on grazing, Peck's milk
mantra couldn't be more different. "The best milk is milk
that's unhomogenized, unpasteurized, grass-fed, in a glass
bottle, from a farm within 20, 30 miles of you," Peck said.
-
- That sort of certainty is harder to come by in the
supermarket aisles, even for consumers up on the latest
nutrition news.
-
- Greg Resch, general manager of David's Natural Market in
Columbia, buys Horizon Organic Milk Plus DHA Omega-3 Whole
Milk Ultra Pasteurized for his family. The milk costs a
whopping $4.99 for a half-gallon at David's, a small store
that devotes an entire four-door refrigerated case to milk.
-
- Resch chooses that particular milk because it is
supplemented with docosahexaenoic acid or DHA, an omega-3
fatty acid that's derived from algae and thought to promote
brain development. His kids aren't big on fish, another
source of the nutrient, so the milk is his way of slipping a
little brain food into their diet.
-
- Resch isn't thrilled that the milk is ultra-pasteurized,
heated to a temperature higher than what's necessary for
normal pasteurization. That's done to extend the shelf life
for many brands of organic milk, which tend to sit longer in
the store because they're pricey.
-
- Some suspect the high heat - the same thing that keeps
those little "shelf-stable" milk boxes fresh outside the
fridge - zaps all the good stuff out of milk.
-
- Resch just weighs the pros and cons, tries to make the
best choice, and accepts the fact that nothing's perfect.
-
- "It can get almost crazy sometimes," he said. "You can
only do so much to Mother Nature."
-
- deciphering the dairy case
- Milk: Conventional milk comes from cows that may
have been treated with antibiotics and injected with
synthetic growth hormone. The animals also may eat feed
treated with chemical pesticides.
-
- No added hormones: Milk from cows not treated
with synthetic bovine growth hormones (called rBGH and BST
on some labels). Sometimes billed as "hormone-free," but
that's a misnomer, since all milk has naturally occurring
hormones.
-
- Organic: From cows not treated with antibiotics
or artificial growth hormones. The animals also eat feed
raised without chemical fertilizers or pesticides and must
have "access to pasture." How often do the cows have grass
under hoof? No telling. The government has not defined
"access to pasture."
-
- Grass-fed: Milk from cows that spend at least
some of their time grazing. How much of their diet is grass?
Another undefined term, another unknown.
-
- Plus DHA: Milk supplemented with a supposedly
brain-boosting omega-3 fatty acid derived from algae.
-
- Homogenized: Milk that has been pressurized to
evenly distribute the fat, so the cream doesn't rise to the
top. Almost all of the milk on the market fits this
description.
-
- Nonhomogenized: The fat is not blasted into tiny
bits in this variety, produced by some niche dairies. Before
pouring, shake the bottle to mix in the cream or scoop it
off for your coffee.
-
- Pasteurized: Milk heated to 161 degrees to kill
off potentially harmful bacteria.
-
- Ultra-pasteurized: Milk heated to 280 degrees, a
temperature higher than what's needed for pasteurization, to
extend its shelf life.
-
- Raw or unpasteurized: From the cow's udder to
your lips. Because the milk's not heated, no nutrients are
lost, devotees claim. But drinkers risk illness - and arrest
if they buy it in Maryland, where sales are illegal.
-
- Copyright 2009 Baltimore Sun.
-
-
Exercise
can reduce scoliosis symptoms
-
- Ask the expert: Charles Edwards II, Mercy Medical Center
- Baltimore Sun
- Tuesday, June 9, 2009
-
- Scoliosis, an abnormal curvature of the spine, affects
roughly 2 percent of the population, according to the
American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. For National
Scoliosis Awareness Month, Dr. Charles Edwards II of the
Maryland Spine Center at Mercy Medical Center offers five
things you should know about the disease.
-
- •Abnormal curvature of the spine is termed scoliosis. It
typically increases in size during the years of most rapid
growth. Children with scoliosis are evaluated with spine
X-rays every six to 12 months.
-
- •For children and adolescents with moderate curves,
rigid bracing of the spine can help prevent worsening of the
deformity. For larger curves, surgery is often recommended
to prevent further worsening during adulthood and to improve
the appearance of the deformity.
-
- •Scoliosis can develop or worsen as the cushions within
the spine (disks) age and flatten. Adults with mild
scoliosis are typically asymptomatic. Adults with larger
scoliosis curves often experience increasing back pain and
compression of the nerves within the spine. Such
compression, called sciatica, can cause pain, numbness and
weakness in the legs.
-
- •Regular exercise, smoking avoidance and
anti-inflammatory medications are useful for preventing and
minimizing symptoms. If the deformity becomes severe or the
symptoms debilitating, then surgery may be advisable.
-
- •Surgery typically involves straightening of the
deformity, opening up the space for the nerves and placement
of metal implants to stabilize the spine. A spinal deformity
surgeon helps determine whether a limited minimally invasive
procedure is appropriate or if a larger, more comprehensive
surgery is required.
-
- Copyright 2009 Baltimore Sun.
-
-
MARYLAND Lawmakers request $30M for emergency preparedness
-
- Delmarva Media Group
- Salisbury Daily Times
- Tuesday, June 9, 2009
-
- CHEVERLY, Md. — Two Maryland lawmakers are asking for
$30 million in federal funding to create the
Maryland/National Capital Region Emergency Preparedness
Partnership.
-
- Democrats Sen. Barbara Mikulski and Rep. Donna Edwards
visited Prince George's Hospital Center on Monday to
announce their requests that would make the hospital a key
player in the region's emergency preparedness efforts.
-
- The lawmakers say the partnership would coordinate the
region's response in a large-scale emergency and could go
toward hospital response to pandemics and other disasters.
-
- The partnership would also include Malcolm Grow Medical
Center at Andrews Air Force Base and the University of
Maryland Medical System.
-
- Mikulski has requested $5 million and Edwards has
requested $25 million. Their requests must go through the
appropriations process.
-
- Copyright 2009 Salisbury Daily Times.
-
-
Funds
Sought for Preparedness Partnership
-
- By Lori Aratani
- Washington Post
- Tuesday, June 9, 2009
-
- Two Maryland lawmakers are asking for $30 million in
federal funding to make Prince George's Hospital Center a
key player in efforts to boost the region's emergency
preparedness.
-
- At a news conference at the hospital yesterday, Sen.
Barbara A. Mikulski (D) and Rep. Donna F. Edwards (D-Prince
George's) said the money would fund the creation of the
Maryland-National Capital Region Emergency Preparedness
Partnership. Edwards asked for $25 million in federal funds
for fiscal 2010, and Mikulski asked for $5 million.
-
- The lawmakers said the partnership would coordinate the
response to a large-scale medical emergency caused by a
biological, chemical or nuclear attack. The money could also
fund the hospital's response to pandemics and other
disasters that could cause significant casualties.
-
- The partnership would include Malcolm Grow Medical
Center at Andrews Air Force Base and the University of
Maryland Medical Systems. Prince George's Hospital Center
would serve as the central facility for training and trauma
surge capacity, the lawmakers said.
-
- Copyright 2009 Washington Post.
-
-
State, county officials take the heat at Ridgely Middle
-
- Catonsville Times
- Tuesday, June 9, 2009
-
- Parents say heat inside school makes for poor learning
environment
-
- Elected officials and parents of children who attend
Ridgely Middle School in Lutherville toured the school
Monday to express concern about what parents say is
excessive heat in school building.
-
- Parents and teachers say some parts of the school are so
hot they create an inhospitable learning environment and are
even causing health problems for students.
-
- In Stephanie Strayers second floor classroom, it was 87
degrees on Monday, with nearly 60 percent humidity,
according to a digital weather station in her room.
-
- Thats a heat index of 90 degrees, Julie Sugar said after
checking a temperature chart.
-
- Strayer said she typically has up to 35 students in her
room. A full room can make her sixth grade world cultures
class even hotter.
-
- Last week, it was 94 degrees in here while the students
were taking their final exams, Strayer said.
-
- Ridgely Middle, built in the mid-1960s, underwent about
$14 million in renovations nearly two years ago. The
renovations included energy-efficient windows, which dont
let in as much air as the old windows did. A chiller unit
that would have cooled the school was part of the original
plans, but was never installed.
-
- The chiller could still be added to the school at a cost
of about $966,000, according to Sen. Jim Brochin, a Democrat
who represents the 42nd District, which includes Towson,
Timonium and part of Pikesville.
-
- The new windows open inside and only at a 30-degree
angle. The old windows opened outward and at a 90-degree
angle.
-
- The school system faced criticism from the County
Council during last months budget hearings. The councils
budget message asked the school to provide a report on how
it is addressing the concerns of parents as well as
information on other schools that are in a similar
condition. The school system has until June 30 to respond.
-
- What other schools have similar situations? Councilman
Kevin Kamenetz asked after the tour. If its just Ridgely,
then fix it.
-
- Copyright 2009 Catonsville Times.
-
-
-
-
Maryland Department of Environment issues 80 enforcement
actions
-
- By Scott Dance
- Baltimore Business Journal
- Tuesday, June 9, 2009
-
- The Maryland Department of Environment has fined more
than two dozen Baltimore-area businesses for pollution
violations.
-
- The department issued 80 enforcement actions in total
Tuesday, seeking penalties of $576,000.
-
- The violations included:
-
- • A lack of air quality permits at a crushing plant
owned by P&J Contracting of Baltimore, for a $31,000 fine;
-
- • An emergency discharge of air emissions at Air
Products in Sparrows Point, for a $25,000 fine;
-
- • Failure to meet air quality permit standards at Sunoco
Partners Marketing and Terminals LP in Baltimore County;
-
- • Improper protection for workers of Southern Insulation
during asbestos removal at the Sparrows Point Steel Mill;
-
- • Lead paint at properties owned by Charm City Housing
Associates Inc., Rent Man Limited, 3401 Woodbrook LLC, 1645
N. Calhoun Holdings LLC, and Mortgage Solutions Consulting
Group LLC;
-
- • Improper patient exposure to X-ray radiation at Johns
Hopkins Hospital, with a $7,500 fine.
-
- Other settlements for radiation exposure were made with:
-
- • Dentist Mark S. Blank in Reisterstown,
-
- • Dentist Edward J. Sattler in Baltimore,
-
- • Arbutus Veterinary Hospital,
-
- • H.M. Dunstan & Associates PA in Baltimore,
-
- • Edmondson Family Dental Care in Baltimore,
-
- • SurgiCenter of Baltimore in Owings Mills,
-
- • Dentist Lincoln O. Frank in Baltimore,
-
- • Dentist Paul E. Freed in Towson,
-
- • Seton Imaging Center in Baltimore,
-
- • Dentist Garry D. Snydman in Owings Mills,
-
- • Dentist Karl J. Zeren in Timonium,
-
- • Chase Brexton Health Services Inc. in Baltimore,
-
- • Mandel Keiser & Joseph LLP in Owings Mills,
-
- • Dentist Thomas F. Menton in Ellicott City,
-
- • Dentist Michael L. DiPaula in Baltimore,
-
- • Dundalk Cosmetic and Family Dental Center,
-
- • Sarubin Family Dental Associates in Baltimore,
-
- • Dentist Lynn R. Chincheck in Timonium, and,
-
- • Dentist Richard N. Lamb in Baltimore.
-
- Radiation fines ranged from $250 to $1,000.
-
- All contents of this site © American City Business
Journals Inc. All rights reserved.
-
-
Alternative medicine meets mainstream hospitals
-
- Associated Press
- By Marilynn Marchione
- USA Today
- Tuesday, June 6, 2009
-
- BALTIMORE — At one of the nation's top trauma hospitals,
a nurse circles a patient's bed, humming and waving her arms
as if shooing evil spirits. Another woman rubs a quartz bowl
with a wand, making tunes that mix with the beeping monitors
and hissing respirator keeping the man alive.
-
- They are doing Reiki therapy, which claims to heal
through invisible energy fields. The anesthesia chief, Dr.
Richard Dutton, calls it "mystical mumbo jumbo." Still, he's
a fan.
-
- "It's self-hypnosis" that can help patients relax, he
said. "If you tell yourself you have less pain, you actually
do have less pain."
-
- Alternative medicine has become mainstream. It is
finding wider acceptance by doctors, insurers and hospitals
like the shock trauma center at the University of Maryland
Medical Center. Consumer spending on it in some cases rivals
that of traditional health care.
-
- People turn to unconventional therapies and herbal
remedies for everything from hot flashes and trouble
sleeping to cancer and heart disease. They crave more "care"
in their health care. They distrust drug companies and the
government. They want natural, safer remedies.
-
- But often, that is not what they get. Government actions
and powerful interest groups have left consumers vulnerable
to flawed products and misleading marketing.
-
- Dietary supplements do not have to be proved safe or
effective before they can be sold. Some contain natural
things you might not want, such as lead and arsenic. Some
interfere with other things you may be taking, such as birth
control pills.
-
- "Herbals are medicines," with good and bad effects, said
Bruce Silverglade of the consumer group Center for Science
in the Public Interest.
-
- Contrary to their little-guy image, many of these
products are made by big businesses.
-
- Ingredients and their countries of origin are a mystery
to consumers. They are marketed in ways that manipulate
emotions, just like ads for hot cars and cool clothes. Some
make claims that average people can't parse as proof of
effectiveness or blather, like "restores cell-to-cell
communication."
-
- Even therapies that may help certain conditions, such as
acupuncture, are being touted for uses beyond their
evidence.
-
- An Associated Press review of dozens of studies and
interviews with more than 100 sources found an underground
medical system operating in plain sight, with a different
standard than the rest of medical care, and millions of
people using it on blind faith.
-
- How did things get this way?
-
- Fifteen years ago, Congress decided to allow dietary and
herbal supplements to be sold without federal Food and Drug
Administration approval. The number of products soared, from
about 4,000 then to well over 40,000 now.
-
- Ten years ago, Congress created a new federal agency to
study supplements and unconventional therapies. But more
than $2.5 billion of tax-financed research has not found any
cures or major treatment advances, aside from certain uses
for acupuncture and ginger for chemotherapy-related nausea.
If anything, evidence has mounted that many of these pills
and therapies lack value.
-
- Yet they are finding ever-wider use:
-
- •Big hospitals and clinics increasingly offer
alternative therapies. Many just offer stress reducers like
meditation, yoga and massage. But some offer treatments with
little or no scientific basis, to patients who are
emotionally vulnerable and gravely ill. The Baltimore
hospital, for example, is not charging for Reiki but wants
to if it can be shown to help. Other hospitals earn fees
from treatments such as acupuncture, which insurance does
not always cover if the purpose is not sufficiently proven.
The giant HMO Kaiser Permanente pays for members to go to a
Portland, Ore., doctor who prescribes ayurvedics —
traditional herbal remedies from India.
-
- •Some medical schools are teaching future doctors about
alternative medicine, sometimes with federal grants. The
goal is educating them about what patients are using so they
can give evidence-based, nonjudgmental care. But some
schools have ties to alternative medicine practitioners and
advocates. A University of Minnesota program lets students
study nontraditional healing methods at a center in Hawaii
supported by a philanthropist fan of such care, though
students pay their own travel and living expenses. A private
foundation that wants wider inclusion of nontraditional
methods sponsors fellowships for hands-on experience at the
University of Arizona's Program in Integrative Medicine,
headed by well-known advocate Dr. Andrew Weil.
-
- •Health insurers are cutting deals to let alternative
medicine providers market supplements and services directly
to members. At least one insurer promotes these to members
with a discount, perhaps leaving an incorrect impression
they are covered services and medically sound. Some insurers
steer patients to Internet sellers of supplements, even
though patients must pay for these out of pocket. There are
networks of alternative medicine providers that contract
with big employers, just like HMOs.
-
- A few herbal supplements can directly threaten health. A
surprising number do not supply what their labels claim,
contain potentially harmful substances like lead, or are
laced with hidden versions of prescription drugs.
-
- "In testing, one out of four supplements has a problem,"
said Dr. Tod Cooperman, president of ConsumerLab.com, an
independent company that rates such products.
-
- Even when the ingredients aren't risky, spending money
for a product with no proven benefit is no small harm when
the economy is bad and people can't afford health insurance
or healthy food.
-
- But sometimes the cost is far greater. Cancer patients
can lose their only chance of beating the disease by
gambling on unproven treatments. People with clogged
arteries can suffer a heart attack. Children can be harmed
by unproven therapies forced on them by parents who distrust
conventional medicine.
-
- Mainstream medicine and prescription drugs have
problems, too. Popular drugs such as the painkillers Vioxx
and Bextra have been pulled from the market after serious
side effects emerged once they were widely used by
consumers. But at least there are regulatory systems,
guideline-setting groups and watchdog agencies helping to
keep traditional medicine in line.
-
- The safety net for alternative medicine is far flimsier.
-
- The latest government survey shows the magnitude of
risk: More than a third of Americans use unconventional
therapies, including acupuncture, homeopathy, chiropractic,
and native or traditional healing methods. These
practitioners are largely self-policing, with their own
schools and accreditation groups. Some states license
certain types, like acupuncturists; others do not.
-
- Tens of millions of Americans take dietary supplements —
vitamins, minerals and herbs, ranging from ginseng and
selenium to fish oil and zinc, said Steven Mister, president
of the Council for Responsible Nutrition, an industry trade
group.
-
- "We bristle when people talk about us as if we're just
fringe," he said. Supplements are "an insurance policy" if
someone doesn't always eat right, he said.
-
- In fact, some are widely recommended by doctors —
prenatal vitamins for pregnant women, calcium for older
women at risk of osteoporosis, and fish oil for some heart
patients, for example. These uses are generally thought to
be safe, although independent testing has found quality
problems and occasional safety concerns with specific
products, such as too much or too little of a vitamin.
-
- Some studies suggest that vitamin deficiencies can raise
the risk of disease. But it is not clear that taking
supplements will fix that, and research has found hints of
harm, said Dr. Jeffrey White, complementary and alternative
medicine chief at the National Cancer Institute. A doctor
with a big interest in nutrition, he sees the field as "an
area of opportunity" that deserves serious study.
-
- So does Dr. Josephine Briggs, director of the National
Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine, the
federal agency Congress created a decade ago.
-
- "Most patients are not treated very satisfactorily,"
Briggs said. "If we had highly effective, satisfactory
conventional treatment we probably wouldn't have as much
need for these other strategies and as much public interest
in them."
-
- Even critics of alternative medicine providers
understand their appeal.
-
- "They give you a lot of time. They treat you like
someone special," said R. Barker Bausell, a University of
Maryland biostatistician who wrote "Snake Oil Science," a
book about flawed research in the field.
-
- That is why Dr. Mitchell Gaynor, a cancer specialist at
the Weill-Cornell Medical Center in New York, said he
includes nutrition testing and counseling, meditation and
relaxation techniques in his treatment, though not everyone
would agree with some of the things he recommends.
-
- "You do have people who will say 'chemotherapy is just
poison,'" said Gaynor, who tells them he doesn't agree.
He'll say: "Cancer takes decades to develop, so you're not
going to be able to think that all of a sudden you're going
to change your diet or do meditation (and cure it). You need
to treat it medically. You can still do things to make your
diet better. You can still do meditation to reduce your
stress."
-
- Once their fears and feelings are acknowledged, most
patients "will do the right thing, do everything they can to
save their life," Gaynor said.
-
- Many people buy supplements to treat life's little
miseries — trouble falling asleep, menopausal hot flashes,
memory lapses, the need to lose weight, sexual problems.
-
- The Dietary Supplement and Health Education Act of 1994
exempted such products from needing FDA approval or proof of
safety or effectiveness before they go on sale.
-
- "That has resulted in consumers wasting billions of
dollars on products of either no or dubious benefit," said
Silverglade of the public interest group.
-
- Many hope that President Barack Obama's administration
will take a new look. In the meantime, some outlandish
claims are drawing a backlash. The industry has stepped up
self-policing — the Council for Responsible Nutrition hired
a lawyer to work with the Council of Better Business Bureaus
and file complaints against problem sellers.
-
- "We certainly don't think this is a huge problem in the
industry," Mister said, but he acknowledges occasionally
seeing infomercials "that promise the world."
-
- "The outliers were making the public feel that this
entire industry was just snake oil and that there weren't
any legitimate products," said Andrea Levine, ad division
chief for the business bureaus.
-
- The FDA just issued its first guidelines for good
manufacturing practices, aimed at improving supplement
safety. Consumer groups say the rules don't go far enough —
for example, they don't set limits on contaminants like lead
and arsenic — but they do give the FDA more leverage after
problems come to light.
-
- The Federal Trade Commission is filing more complaints
about deceptive marketing. One of the largest settlements
occurred last August — $30 million from the makers of
Airborne, a product marketed with a folksy "invented by a
teacher" slogan that claimed to ward off germs spread
through the air.
-
- People need to keep a healthy skepticism about that
magical marketing term "natural," said Kathy Allen, a
dietitian at Moffitt Cancer Center in Tampa
-
- The truth is, supplements lack proof of safety or
benefit. Asked to take a drug under those terms, "most of us
would say 'no,'" Allen said. "When it says 'natural,' the
perception is there is no harm. And that is just not true."
-
- Copyright 2009 The Associated Press. All rights
reserved.
-
- National / International
-
House Democrats to consider taxing health benefits
-
- Associated Press
- By David Espo
- Baltimore Sun
- Tuesday, June 9, 2009
-
- WASHINGTON - Despite a less-than-rousing reaction from
the Obama administration, House Democrats are considering a
new tax on employer-provided health benefits to help pay for
expanding coverage to the uninsured.
-
- Several officials also said an outline of emerging
legislation envisions a requirement for all individuals to
purchase affordable coverage, with an unspecified penalty
for those who refuse and a waiver for those who cannot cover
the cost.
-
- "There's no sense having a mandate unless you have a
contribution," Rep. Charles Rangel, D-N.Y., chairman of the
House Ways and Means Committee, said Monday. He referred to
the suggestion as "play or pay."
-
- Rangel and other senior Democrats arranged to bring
members of the party's rank and file up to date at a midday
session Tuesday on the effort to draft health care
legislation at the top of President Barack Obama's agenda.
-
- No details were available on the possible tax on health
benefits, and several officials stressed that no final
decisions would be made for several days.
-
- The idea has been gaining currency in recent weeks as
Congress intensifies its search for more than $1 trillion to
help pay for a health care overhaul.
-
- Sen. Max Baucus, D-Mont., first floated the idea several
weeks ago, and emerged from a White House meeting last week
saying Obama was open to it.
-
- Obama's top aides did not disagree, even though the
president attacked the idea lustily last year when campaign
rival John McCain proposed it. Instead, White House
officials say Obama prefers his own suggestions: cuts in
projected Medicare spending and tax increases on the wealthy
that thus far have gained little favor among Democrats in
Congress.
-
- Several officials said the House legislation will
include a government-run insurance option as well as plans
offered by private companies. The government option draws
near-unanimous opposition from Republicans and provokes
concerns among many Democrats as well, although Obama has
spoken out in favor of it.
-
- The officials spoke on condition of anonymity, saying
they did not want to pre-empt the presentation to
rank-and-file Democrats on Tuesday.
-
- Under the House Democratic plan, individuals and small
businesses would be able to purchase coverage from a "health
exchange" and the government would require all plans to
contain a minimum benefit, these officials added. No
applicant could be rejected for pre-existing conditions, nor
could one be charged a higher premium, they said.
-
- House Democrats also are considering a wide-ranging
change for Medicaid that would provide a uniform benefit
across all 50 states and increase payments to providers,
according to several officials. Medicaid is a joint
state-federal program of health coverage for the poor.
-
- The disclosures came as the pace of activity quickened
in both the House and Senate on health insurance
legislation. Obama scheduled a meeting Tuesday at the White
House with several Democrats.
-
- Party leaders hope to pass legislation in both houses by
early August and complete work on a compromise measure in
the fall for Obama's signature.
-
- The president has stepped up his own involvement in the
issue in recent days, and there has been a flurry of
negotiations involving outside interest groups who have
pledged to take steps to achieve savings within the private
insurance market.
-
- Alongside those efforts, financing Obama's plan to
spread coverage more widely carries a price tag estimated at
more than $1 trillion over a decade. House Democrats are
considering cutting projected Medicare payments to home
health care, pharmaceutical companies, insurance companies,
hospitals and others to cover costs, but not on the scale
that the president proposed last winter.
-
- The option for taxing insurance benefits is also under
consideration as part of legislation taking shape across the
Capitol in the Senate Finance Committee.
-
- Numerous options are possible, many of which involve
either a tax levied according to the value of an
individual's employer-provided health plan or on the
benefits received by upper-income taxpayers.
-
- The issue poses multiple potential problems for Obama,
who has pledged not to raise taxes on individuals making
less than $250,000 and also ran commercials criticizing
McCain's call for a tax on health benefits in last fall's
campaign.
-
- In recent weeks, the president and his aides have sought
to straddle the issue, neither accepting it nor ruling it
out.
-
- Associated Press writer Ricardo Alonso-Zaldivar
contributed to this report.
-
- Copyright 2009 Baltimore Sun.
-
-
Exercising
for back pain relief
- A strength-training program in a recent study reduced
back pain and improved quality of life for participants.
-
- From the Los Angeles Times
- By Jeannine Stein
- Baltimore Sun
- Tuesday, June 9, 2009
-
- More is better when it comes to alleviating lower back
pain -- more exercise, that is.
-
- Although many people who suffer from back pain don't
exercise, fearing it will exacerbate the problem, a recent
study found that exercising four days a week gave people
greater relief from back pain than working out fewer times
per week or not at all.
-
- In the study, 120 people were randomly assigned to one
of four groups for 12 weeks: One did a strength-training
program two days a week, one did it three days a week, and
one did it four days a week. A control group did no exercise
but participated in a two-week exercise familiarization
program. Exercises in the program included bench presses,
lat pull downs and leg presses.
-
- Those in the four-day-a-week program had the most
reduction in pain -- 28% -- compared with 14% for those who
exercised two days a week. The four-day group also reported
having a better quality of life and less disability than
those who exercised less. In addition, it showed the
greatest strength gains. The control group showed
insignificant change in all areas.
-
- The study was presented recently at the annual meeting
of the American College of Sports Medicine in Seattle.
-
- Copyright 2009 Baltimore Sun.
-
-
Body of lies: Patients aren't 100% honest with doctors
- When patients aren't truthful, misled doctors may give a
wrong diagnosis or treatment.
-
- By Karen Ravn
- Baltimore Sun
- Tuesday, June 9, 2009
-
- Bill Moore of Pacific Grove was barely in his 20s when
he found out he had cholesterol trouble.
-
- This was bad news for Moore because his father had died
of a heart attack at 45 and because, as he told his doctor,
Moore was eating all the right stuff.
-
- The doctor prescribed cholesterol-lowering medication,
and a subsequent test showed the drug was working very well.
Too well.
-
- His doctor was very surprised, Moore says. "I told him I
must be unique. I must have a unique body composition." But
the truth was Moore had fed his doctor a false written
record of his eating habits before beginning the drug --
reporting vegetables and salads that had never been on his
menu, and not reporting all the hamburgers and pizzas that
had.
-
- Only when he started on the cholesterol drug did he
finally begin eating the way he'd been claiming to eat all
along. It was that change combined with the drug that made
his cholesterol levels plunge.
-
- Inaccurate information can do more than confuse a
doctor. It can lead to misinterpreted symptoms, overlooked
warning signs, flawed diagnoses and treatments --
potentially endangering a patient's health, even life.
-
- Still, doctors know that at least some of the time, at
least some of their patients overstate, understate,
embellish, omit, or otherwise stray from a straight and
thorough reporting.
-
- "Everybody lies at some point," says Dr. Sharon Parish,
a professor of clinical medicine at Albert Einstein College
of Medicine in New York City who practices at Montefiore
Medical Center. They do it out of embarrassment, to please
the doctor, to avoid a lecture.
-
- But doctors and patient advocates agree that in most
cases, when patients lie, they're pretty much asking for
trouble. Even when telling the truth is unappealing,
"getting into a lying relationship with your physician is
really far more perilous," says Peter Clarke, director of
the Center for Health and Medical Communication at USC and
co-author of the 1998 book "Surviving Modern Medicine."
-
- An early lesson
- That patients lie is one of the basics doctors learn in
medical school. Of 1,500 responders to a 2004 online survey
by WebMD, 45% admitted they hadn't always told it exactly
like it was -- with 13% saying they had "lied," and 32%
saying they had "stretched the truth."
-
- Not included in those figures would be patients who
"lie" without knowing they do so by withholding information
because it slips their mind or they have no idea it could be
useful. (Maybe Aunt Agnes would gladly tell about the time
she snored so loud she woke the neighbors if she knew that a
diagnosis of sleep apnea could depend on it.)
-
- In the WebMD survey, 38% of respondents said they lied
about following doctors' orders and 32% about diet or
exercise. Doctor reports bear this out.
-
- "Patients are strongly motivated to have their doctors
think they're good patients," says Dr. Steven Hahn,
professor of clinical medicine at Albert Einstein College
and an internist at Jacobi Medical Center in New York City.
-
- It's hard to make a good impression when you're on an
examining table in a flimsy, open-backed gown -- a fact that
might make lying that much more tempting. But even fully
clothed, talking face to face across a desk, a patient cedes
authority to the doctor. And people generally like to please
those in authority, says Emanuel Maidenberg, clinical
professor of psychiatry at UCLA.
-
- Patients also are prone to lying about the fact that
they engage in social taboos, things their doctor might not
approve of. In the WebMD survey, 22% lied about smoking, 17%
about sex, 16% about drinking and 12% about recreational
drug use.
-
- "When you're studying psychiatry, you're taught that if
a patient says, 'I use cocaine once a month,' you figure
it's twice a month," says Dr. Robert Klitzman, professor of
clinical psychiatry at Columbia University. "We were taught
to double."
-
- Patients lie because they don't want to be judged,
embarrassed or misunderstood. They lie about pursuing
alternative health remedies because they disagree with their
doctor or because they think an item is none of their
doctor's business.
-
- Doctors, of course, make the case that even deeply
personal matters such as sexual orientation or having an
extramarital affair can affect the care doctors give (how to
interpret symptoms, what tests to order, exams that might be
important). Patients may see only unpleasant invasions of
their privacy -- and a risk that somehow their co-workers,
parents or spouses will find out too.
-
- "We live in complex social webs," Klitzman says.
"Someone will see the forms. . . . People talk."
-
- But co-workers, parents and spouses aren't the only
threats hanging over a patient's head. Health insurance is
another. And so -- not surprisingly -- sometimes people lie
in order to keep something out of their medical records or
out of the hands of their insurance companies.
-
- That can be of genuine concern, say doctors and patient
advocates. What happens in the doctor's office doesn't
always stay in the doctor's office.
-
- Anything and everything health-related that patients
tell their doctors is supposed to go into their medical
records. That information is confidential, protected under
the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability
Act.
-
- But in fact, it's only confidential until it isn't.
-
- Whenever patients apply to buy individual insurance
policies, and whenever they file claims under policies they
own, the insurance company can request their medical
records.
-
- Patients can refuse to release the records, but if they
do, the company can refuse to sell them a policy or refuse
to pay claims. This is part of the deal patients agree to by
signing on to the insurance contract.
-
- And it doesn't take much in a patient's records to nix
the sale of a policy. "A case of acne can do it," says Jerry
Flanagan, an advocate with the Foundation for Taxpayer and
Consumer Rights.
-
- And there are other insurance complications. If, when
processing a claim, the insurance company finds something in
a patient's records that contradicts something the patient
said when purchasing the policy, the company can
retroactively cancel the policy, Flanagan says. Then it can
demand reimbursement for any claims it has already paid --
even if those claims had nothing to do with the reason for
canceling the policy.
-
- "I would never advocate lying to your doctor," Flanagan
says, "but I can definitely understand why someone might."
-
- Dr. Ken Duckworth, medical director of the National
Alliance on Mental Illness, suggests one scenario in which
it might be tempting to lie. Say someone learns from a gene
testing company that she is carrying a gene that puts her at
risk for a disease for which there is no treatment or
prevention. Then, he says, "it could be in a patient's
interest to conceal that information."
-
- Arthur Caplan, director of the Center for Bioethics at
the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia, cites yet
another hypothetical: Say a patient feels deserving of
coverage for a certain condition or treatment, but his
symptoms don't quite fit the insurance company's
requirements. The patient might adapt the description of his
symptoms to qualify for coverage, "and that might arguably
be defensible or excusable."
-
- Accuracy is vital
- Sometimes, a doctor may be willing to help by
overstating a patient's case.
-
- In 1997, Dr. Victor Freeman, then a primary care
research fellow at Georgetown University Medical Center,
asked 167 internists across the country what doctors should
do if one of their patients was at first turned down for
coverage of a treatment that was medically indicated.
-
- Almost half -- 45% -- said it was ethical to lie in
order to get coverage for the patient. The more serious the
condition, the more doctors said lying was appropriate: 57%
when bypass surgery was at stake for a patient with severe
angina or chronic atherosclerosis; 47% when the issue was
comfort care for a patient with terminal ovarian cancer
causing abdominal pain and extreme nausea; 32% when a
patient with severe depression was seeking a psychiatric
referral.
-
- At other times, a doctor may be willing to help by
leaving things out of a patient's record.
-
- Dr. Howard Brody, director of the Institute for the
Medical Humanities at the University of Texas Medical Branch
in Galveston, Texas, suggests patients talk to their doctors
if they have symptoms or conditions they fear could
disqualify them for insurance coverage.
-
- "There may be times when a doctor will agree to not put
it on [record]," he says.
-
- "But that's very iffy. It's not good medical practice as
a rule."
-
- Clarke suggests patients have two sets of medical
records, a private one between patient and doctor and
another for sharing with others.
-
- "The solution is not to lie to your physician but to
establish private records that won't be released to third
parties," he says. "If your physician won't do that, it's
reason enough to leave the physician."
-
- Short of changing to a healthcare system where insurance
companies can't refuse to sell anyone a policy because of a
health condition -- which he favors -- Flanagan says there's
no ideal solution for some patients.
-
- Even so, most doctors, ethicists and patient advocates
think it's a bad idea to lie to a doctor, although they all
see reasons why patients might want to -- and even scenarios
where a lie might be justified.
-
- Some ethicists consider it a moral obligation for
patients to tell the truth to their doctors, Brody says. In
establishing a patient-doctor relationship, the first step
is to take a thorough medical history.
-
- "None of the rest makes any sense without an accurate
history to guide you," he says.
-
- Lying about what you eat, how much exercise you get or
whether you're taking your medication as prescribed may seem
benign but can be hazardous. If it seems you've been doing
everything right, and your condition still isn't improving,
the doctor could change your current treatment plan to
something more serious and invasive -- and unnecessary.
-
- As for embarrassment, perhaps patients worry too much
about what their doctors think of them.
-
- "Doctors have heard it all," Klitzman says. "They've
seen it all."
-
- In other words: Get over yourself.
-
- Copyright © 2009, The Los Angeles Times.
-
-
How to treat a sunburn
-
- Daily Press (Newport News, Va.)
- By Alison Johnson
- Baltimore Sun
- Friday, May 29, 2009
-
- While the best way to deal with sunburn is not to get
one - think sunscreen, limited midday exposure and hats -
here's what to do if you get baked:
-
- Cool it down. Soak a cloth with cool water and rest it
on burns for about 20 minutes. Then apply a balm such as
aloe vera. You also can use a mild lotion - aim for one
without perfume or dye - to help keep skin moisturized.
-
- Bathe with cool water. Don't take hot showers or baths
and avoid cleaning burned areas with soap, which can be an
irritant. Pat your skin dry with a towel instead of rubbing.
-
- Wear comfortable clothes. Choose loose-fitting cotton;
wool and man-made materials such as polyester may chafe
against a burn. You also can lie down a soft cotton blanket
on couches, chairs and beds.
-
- Don't peel your skin. Picking at a burned spot will
irritate it and slow healing.
-
- Stay out of the sun. Some people think that if they're
already burned, it can't get worse. Not true. Wait until
your skin has healed or cover up as much as possible.
-
- Drink lots of water. You can dehydrate more quickly if
you are sunburned.
-
- Take painkillers. If your burns bother you, get an
over-the-counter medicine with acetaminophen or ibuprofen,
such as Tylenol, Advil or Motrin.
-
- Try natural remedies. Some people have had luck with
putting cold, wet teabags on burns or adding a half cup of
baking soda or oatmeal to a cool bath.
-
- See a doctor if needed. Call if your skin blisters or
peels severely. You could be at risk for an infection and
may need medication.
-
- (c) 2009, Daily Press ( Newport News, Va.).
-
- Visit dailypress.com, the World Wide Web site of the
Daily Press at
http://dailypress.com and on America Online at
keyword "dailypress."
-
- Distributed by McClatchy-Tribune Information Services.
-
- Copyright © 2009, Tribune Media Services.
-
-
Peanuts, Anyone?
- Researchers Expose Kids to Risky Foods In Order to Cure
Them
-
- By Rob Stein
- Washington Post
- Tuesday, June 9, 2009
-
- Ever since she was an infant, Reagan Roberts could not
tolerate being anywhere near cow's milk. A mere sip would
leave her vomiting and gasping for breath. If she were even
touched by someone with milk on their hands, she would break
out in hives and a bright red rash.
-
- "We just had to keep her away from milk," said Reagan's
mother, Lissa. "We couldn't have it around the house. At
preschool she had to sit by herself. We brought her food to
birthday parties. We couldn't go to restaurants. It was very
hard."
-
- Today, however, Reagan, 9, of Ellicott City, can drink
as much milk as she wants and eat anything.
-
- "She eats ice cream. She eats cheese. She eats yogurt.
She drinks chocolate milk. She eats any food anybody else
can," Lissa Roberts said. "It's a miracle."
-
- Reagan is one of a small number of children who have
undergone an experimental treatment that is showing promise
for treating milk, peanut and other food allergies. The
approach, known as oral immunotherapy, involves slowly
desensitizing the immune system by painstakingly ingesting
increasing amounts of whatever triggers the reaction.
-
- "It's pretty encouraging," said Robert A. Wood, chief of
pediatric allergy and immunology at Johns Hopkins, who led
the study that Reagan participated in at the Hopkins
Children's Center in Baltimore. "We've still got a long way
to go, but I never thought we'd get this far."
-
- Although the approach appears to be highly effective for
some children with milk and peanut allergies, the
researchers conducting the studies and others caution that
much more research is needed to prove and perfect the
approach and that it is far from ready for widespread use.
No one should try the approach on his own, because the
treatments themselves can trigger potentially
life-threatening reactions.
-
- "It's still very investigational," said Wesley Burks,
chief of the division of pediatric allergy and immunology at
Duke University, who has produced promising results in
children with peanut allergies. "We're very hopeful. But
there are lot of things we need to do to understand it
better, make it more effective and make sure it's safe."
-
- The strategy is being tested in a handful of small
studies that are part of a surge of research in a field that
for years showed little progress.
-
- "There's been a substantial uptick in the amount of
research," said Marshall Plaut of the National Institute of
Allergy and Infectious Diseases, which has more than doubled
the funding for food-allergy research since 2007. "I think
it's time to be cautiously optimistic."
-
- In addition to the oral immunotherapy studies,
scientists are in the early stages of testing an
experimental suppository, a Chinese herbal remedy and
variations of oral immunotherapy that might be safer and
more effective.
-
- "There's definitely been a spike in the amount of work
going on," said Hugh A. Sampson, a professor of pediatrics,
allergy and immunology at the Mount Sinai School of Medicine
in New York who leads a federally funded consortium studying
food allergies. "Five years ago there was almost nothing
going on in people with respect to therapies, whereas now
there are a variety of different therapies being looked at."
-
- Why the Increase?
- The spike in research has been driven by increasing
evidence that food allergies are becoming more common,
occurring earlier in life and lasting longer. About 12
million Americans are estimated to suffer from food
allergies, including about 3 million children. Some evidence
suggests that peanut allergies may have doubled in children
in the past decade.
-
- The reason for the trend is the subject of intense
research and debate. There are several theories, including
changes in how food is processed and children's not being
exposed to certain foods early in life. Evidence has also
been mounting for the "hygiene hypothesis," which blames
growing up in increasingly sterile homes, making the immune
system overreact to ordinarily harmless substances,
including food.
-
- Whatever the cause, researchers have long struggled to
develop therapies. Food allergies can trigger symptoms
ranging from rashes and hives to responses believed to cause
perhaps 200 deaths each year in the United States.
Currently, food-allergic people have only two options: to
avoid the substance that causes their reaction or to try to
stop a reaction with an injection of epinephrine.
-
- That leaves parents of allergic children scouring food
labels, avoiding restaurants, sending their children to
school and parties with specially made food and snacks, and
still worrying about inadvertent contact with peanuts, milk,
eggs and other ubiquitous foods.
-
- "It's hard to live," said Angie Duty of Durham, N.C.,
whose 9-year-old son, Sam, was intensely allergic to peanuts
before undergoing the therapy as part of one Burks's
studies. "Sam doesn't like to be different, but of course he
is different and we have to explain that to him."
-
- Although doctors have long used shots to desensitize
people allergic to pollen and other substances, early
attempts to do the same for food allergies ended in failure.
-
- "The side effects were so great that they were as bad if
not worse than the disease itself," Burks said.
-
- But a small number of researchers in recent years have
begun trying the approach again, this time by orally
administering the protein in the food that triggers the
allergic reaction.
-
- With doctors standing by in case of a severe reaction,
each study subject undergoes careful testing to determine
the maximum dose he or she can safely tolerate. Once that is
established, the participants are sent home to sprinkle that
amount of purified protein on their food for a week or two;
then they return to the research center in to see if the
dose can be increased. The procedure is repeated for months
or even years to slowly raise the amount they can safely
consume.
-
- "It's a way of sort of rerouting or tricking the immune
system to no longer be allergic to that food," said Stacie
Jones, chief of allergy and immunology at the Arkansas
Children's Hospital, who has been working Burks to test the
approach for peanut allergies.
-
- In a study involving 19 children who were severely
allergic to milk, Wood found that within four to six months
most of the children significantly increased the amount of
milk protein they could tolerate. After between about nine
months and two years, about half of the children could
safely consume as much milk or food containing milk as they
wanted.
-
- "These are children who could have died from a teaspoon
of milk before," Wood said.
-
- No More Reactions
- In March, Burks and Jones reported the results of a
pilot study involving 33 children with peanut allergies. The
children started by ingesting peanut protein powder
equivalent to one one-thousandth of a peanut. Four of the
children had to drop out because of allergic reactions, but
six of nine children who underwent the treatment for 2 1/2
years have been able to stop the peanut powder and have now
gone six to eight months without reacting to eating peanuts.
"It's fabulous," said Janet Vande Berg of Durham, N.C.,
whose 9-year-old daughter, Caroline, can eat peanuts for the
first time in her life. "It makes a huge, huge difference in
the quality of life for both the kids and the families. It
just takes the stress away."
-
- The researchers are tracking the remaining children in
the study to see if any others achieve similar results and
have followed up with a more stringent study in which 13
children received a similar treatment and seven received a
placebo.
-
- After about 10 months, all seven children on the placebo
were still allergic, whereas none of the 13 on the peanut
powder had reactions when they were challenged. All the
children are now receiving the treatment and are being
followed to see if they remain desensitized and perhaps
become "tolerant," meaning they no longer need to consume
daily doses of peanuts or peanut protein to maintain their
ability to eat peanuts freely.
-
- "I think it's an important advance in the field," said
the NIH's Plaut. "It's a small number of subjects, so it's
hard to draw full-blown conclusions. But it's the first data
that suggest you may be able to achieve something like this
in food allergies."
-
- It remains far from clear, however, what proportion of
children will benefit, how long the benefit might last and
what proportion will need to continue to consume at least
some milk or peanuts every day to maintain their protection.
While some children, such as Vande Berg, appear to
completely lose their allergies, others seem to just be able
to eat more of the milk or food before reacting. But even
that can be helpful.
-
- "We know this therapy at least protects them from
accidental ingestion so they won't have a life-threatening
reaction," said Jones, the Arkansas researcher. "At the very
least it's providing some security for these families."
-
- Burks and Jones are part of the federal consortium,
which is studying the same approach for eggs at research
institutions across the country, including Johns Hopkins,
and conducting detailed immunological studies to try to get
a better understanding of how the treatment works.
-
- Meanwhile, researchers in London are studying 640 babies
at high risk for food allergies to see if exposing them to
peanuts early in life reduces their chances of developing
the allergy in the first place.
-
- "There are a lot of people putting ideas out there and
producing some promising preliminary data," Plaut said.
"That makes me think there will be some important
developments in the future."
-
- Copyright 2009 Washington Post.
-
-
Coming
Clean About Risk of Finger Food
-
- By Sindya N. Bhanoo
- Washington Post
- Tuesday, June 9, 2009
-
- Come lunchtime, Washingtonians step out of their
germ-laden offices to grab a bite to eat. And likely as not,
they'll be eating with their fingers.
-
- There are Indian restaurants, with naan that spice
lovers dip into curry. And Ethiopian, with injera, the crepe
broken off with the fingers and eaten with vegetable and
meat stews.
-
- At Nando's Peri-Peri, which opened in Washington's
Chinatown last summer, the juicy chicken is finger-licking
good, as many customers prove while enjoying their meals.
-
- But all this food touching means the germs from our
hands are also touching our food.
-
- With the wide variety of ethnic finger foods available
today, along with classics such as french fries and nachos,
should more of us be washing our hands before sitting down
to eat at restaurants?
-
- Yes, says Charles Gerba, a microbiologist at the
University of Arizona. Especially at lunchtime.
-
- Gerba is the germ guy. He has spent years swiping cotton
swabs across the floors of bathrooms, counters, tables and
door handles, trying to figure out where the ickiest of
germs live.
-
- "Eighty percent of us work indoors; we're sharing more
spaces with more people than ever before," he said.
-
- The work environment is crawling with bacteria, he has
found.
-
- "Our offices -- our desktops, our keyboards, our phones
-- these are among the worst places for germs," he said.
"There are 400 times more viruses on the average desktop
than the average toilet, for instance."
-
- Yuck.
-
- The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
recommends that we always wash our hands in warm water with
soap before eating.
-
- But 35 percent of Americans don't always wash their
hands before lunch, according to a 2008 survey conducted for
the Soap and Detergent Association, a trade group.
-
- I began thinking about hand-washing because my parents
are from India, and I grew up eating Indian food almost
every day. We ate it with our hands -- after washing them.
-
- But at Indian restaurants, I rarely see patrons making
their way to the restroom to wash up before dipping their
fingers into a plate of samosas or tearing a piece of naan
in half to scoop up some chicken tikka masala.
-
- In India, it is common to see sinks with running water
and soap in the seating area of restaurants, so customers
can wash up before and after eating. A few years ago when I
was visiting India, I thought to myself, why not do this in
America?
-
- Some restaurants do. Nando's has sinks in the seating
area. The question is whether patrons use them.
-
- I stood in a corner of the restaurant during lunch one
day (shortly after the swine flu outbreak began, in fact)
and started counting.
-
- One, two, three, four, five . . . six . . . all the way
up to 58, in a half-hour.
-
- That was my count of how many people walked by the very
prominently located sink and didn't wash their hands. They
did stop, though, to pick up dipping sauce and napkins,
which were located right next to the sink.
-
- I counted three, yes three, people who did wash their
hands: two middle-aged men and one young woman.
-
- The two men were together, so I joined them in their
lunch booth to find out what inspired them to wash.
-
- "I always wash my hands before I eat," said Mark Raby,
48. "And I like the sink out here; in fact, maybe this will
encourage more people to wash."
-
- His lunch companion, Jamie MacAyeal, is not always so
diligent.
-
- "At home, in general I do," said Mac-Ayeal, 52. "But not
always when I eat out. Our bodies can fight germs."
-
- Raby disagreed.
-
- "Your skin comes into contact with all kinds of
pathogens, and why ingest these?" he asked.
-
- "It's like how there's two schools of thought for
infants," MacAyeal said, explaining that some pediatricians
say that kids should be kept away from germs, while others
say exposure to germs builds immunity.
-
- "My dad was a pediatrician," Raby said, eyeing his
friend with skepticism. "And he taught me to wash my hands."
-
- Other restaurants offer different solutions.
-
- At Zed's, a popular Ethiopian restaurant in Georgetown,
waiters bring every customer a disposable hand wipe before
and after they eat.
-
- And at Marrakesh, a Moroccan restaurant neat the
convention center, waiters pour warm rose water on
customers' hands over a brass bowl and then hand them small
towels.
-
- "This is customary in Morocco because we eat with our
hands," said Andre Helou, the restaurant's manager.
"Everyone is clean before they eat; it gives a good
feeling."
-
- Though most customers at Marrakesh do eat with their
hands, the restaurant also provides silverware. "Couscous
can be hard to eat with your fingers," Helou said, "though
traditionally, we form it into small balls with our fingers
and place it our mouth."
-
- Until eight years ago, at Meskerem, an Ethiopian
restaurant in Adams Morgan, waiters took soap, a pitcher of
warm water and bowls to pour water over people's hands. "We
tried to show people the traditional way, but everything
costs money," said manager Mohaba Mohaba.
-
- Many Americans today are familiar with how Ethiopian
food is eaten anyway, he added. "And when we have newcomers
we tell them they might like to wash their hands before
eating."
-
- Gerba, who has been to Marrakesh when visiting
Washington, says restaurants should encourage hand-washing.
-
- "When possible, you should be using soap," he said.
"Hands are pretty efficient at picking up viruses."
-
- Does the germ doctor wash his hands every time he eats?
-
- "I sure do," Gerba said. "It's probably always a good
idea. But if you're not touching the food and you're using
knives and forks, it's not as a critical."
-
- Copyright 2009 Washington Post.
-
-
Decision Makers Differ on How To Mend Broken Health System
-
- By Ceci Connolly
- Washington Post
- Tuesday, June 9, 2009
-
- Nowhere else in the world is so much money spent with
such poor results.
-
- On that point there is rare unanimity among Washington
decision makers: The U.S. health system needs a major
overhaul.
-
- For more than a decade, researchers have documented the
inequities, shortcomings, waste and even dangers in the
hodgepodge of uncoordinated medical services that consume
nearly one-fifth of the nation's economy. Exorbitant medical
bills thrust too many families into bankruptcy, hinder the
global competitiveness of U.S. companies and threaten the
government's long-term solvency.
-
- But the consensus breaks down on the question of how
best to create a coordinated, high-performing,
evidence-based system that provides the right care at the
right time to the right people.
-
- During eight years in office, President George W. Bush
took an incremental approach, adding prescription drug
benefits to the Medicare program for seniors and the
disabled and expanding the number of community clinics
nationwide. President Obama, like the last Democrat to
occupy the White House, contends that was insufficient and
is pushing for an ambitious reworking of the entire $2.3
trillion system.
-
- Framed by President Bill Clinton 16 years ago as a moral
imperative to deliver health care to all, this summer's
historic debate comes against a more urgent backdrop. As the
national unemployment rate nears 10 percent and giants such
as General Motors crumble, the expensive, inefficient health
system has deepened the country's economic woes.
-
- By virtually every measure, the situation has worsened.
-
- Today, about 46 million Americans have no health
insurance, so they go without or wait in emergency rooms for
expensive, belated care. Everyone else helps pay for that
Band-Aid fix in the form of higher taxes and an extra $1,000
a year in insurance premiums.
-
- Pockets of medical excellence dot the landscape, but at
least 100,000 people die each year from infections they
acquired in the hospital, while 1.5 million are harmed by
medication errors. Of 37 industrialized nations, the United
States ranks 29th in infant mortality and among the world's
worst on measures such as obesity, heart disease and
preventable deaths.
-
- Bright young physicians trained at prestigious and
expensive universities enter a profession built on perverse
financial rewards. They, like assembly-line workers of the
past, are paid on a piecemeal basis, earning more money not
by doing better but simply by doing more.
-
- Yet more care rarely translates into better health.
Extensive research by Dartmouth College has found the exact
opposite: Health outcomes are often best in communities that
spend less compared with cities such as Boston and Miami
where the medical arms race of specialists and high-tech
gadgets often leads to greater risks and injuries.
-
- The Institute of Medicine estimates that one-third of
all medical care is pure waste, such as duplicate X-rays,
repeat lab tests and procedures to fix mistakes.
-
- "Most Americans don't understand how bad health care in
the United States is," said Michael F. Cannon, head of
health policy at the libertarian Cato Institute. "We need
big reforms."
-
- Across the ideological spectrum, the diagnosis is
remarkably consistent.
-
- "Sure, some people here have the best health care in the
world, but the average American is paying too much and not
getting enough in return," said John D. Podesta, who led
Obama's transition team and heads the Center for American
Progress, a think tank.
-
- Said Sen. Judd Gregg (R-N.H.): "What's tragic is that so
much of this spending is on duplicative or unnecessary care
that doesn't improve health outcomes."
-
- Simply put, the goal of health reform is to finally get
our money's worth, say industry leaders, policymakers,
consumers and business executives.
-
- They envision a health-care system that guarantees a
basic level of care for everyone, shifts the emphasis to
wellness and prevention, minimizes errors, and reduces
unnecessary and unproved treatment. Such a system would
coordinate care, track patients and doctor performance
electronically, and reward good results. The high-value
system of the future would be organized "so that people get
the care they need and need the care they get," said
Elizabeth A. McGlynn, associate director of the health
research division of Rand Corp.
-
- Nowadays, that is often not the case.
-
- On average, Americans receive the recommended, proven
care 55 percent of the time, according to Rand studies.
Sometimes, doctors or nurses overlook a basic but critical
step, such as prescribing a beta blocker medication to
patients after a heart attack, a therapy shown to
significantly reduce the risk of a fatal attack. At other
times, patients undergo procedures when there is no evidence
that they are any better than a simpler, cheaper
alternative.
-
- Ten years ago, in its landmark report "To Err is Human,"
the Institute of Medicine estimated that 44,000 to 98,000
people die each year from medical mistakes, highlighting the
need for improvement. Since then, the tally has risen, said
Janet Corrigan, president of the National Quality Forum, a
nonprofit membership organization that promotes quality
standards.
-
- "We now know estimates of those who die from
hospital-acquired infections is upwards of 100,000," she
said. "Many of those, if not most, are avoidable and
preventable."
-
- Sen. Robert C. Byrd's recent hospital stay, for example,
has been extended because the West Virginia Democrat
developed a staph infection.
-
- "Everyone agrees that hospitals are hazardous to your
health," said Mitchell Seltzer, a consultant who advises
large medical institutions. "For every day a patient is in a
bed, they are subjected to a higher probability of medical
errors, hospital-acquired infections, inappropriate tests
that do not have a direct bearing on the medical condition
being treated."
-
- Part of the problem is cultural, said Rand's McGlynn.
-
- "People tend to demand the new thing even if there's not
much evidence it will make a difference in the length or
quality of life," she said.
-
- Few patients or physicians have any idea who delivers
good, or bad, care, because few organizations track results.
Consumers have more information to evaluate their cars than
they do their surgeons.
-
- "It's like a doctor flying the plane without
instruments," said James N. Weinstein, a spine surgeon who
directs the Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and
Clinical Practice.
-
- Obama set aside $19 billion in his economic stimulus
package to promote the use of digital records, on the belief
that they reduce duplication, produce more consistent care
and cut down on errors.
-
- Because the fee-for-service payment system rewards
quantity over quality, there is little incentive -- and
there are even disincentives -- for doctors, nurses and
hospitals to improve, Corrigan said.
-
- "Is it a surprise we have lots of extra imaging tests
and lab tests?" she said. "Not at all."
-
- The consequences are especially glaring in regions with
larger numbers of specialists and pricey technology, the
Dartmouth data show.
-
- Take the case of Miami vs. La Crosse, Wis. In 2006,
using inflation-adjusted figures, Medicare spent $5,812 on
the average beneficiary in La Crosse, compared with $16,351
in Miami. Yet an examination of health status in both
places, adjusted for age, finds no evidence that the extra
spending resulted in better care, Weinstein said.
-
- "That's the enigma here," he said. "Less is more, and
more isn't better."
-
- Physician behavior and spending patterns in Medicare
have been good indicators of broader trends across the
nation, Dartmouth has found.
-
- Even the best physicians cannot stay current with all of
the drugs, tests and treatments available today -- another
reason to digitize modern medicine, Corrigan said.
-
- Many fear that the push to contain costs will result in
rationing.
-
- In today's system, "we don't ration care, we ration
people," said Donald M. Berwick, president of the
independent Massachusetts-based Institute for Healthcare
Improvement. "We know that if you are black and poor or a
woman, there are all sorts of effective interventions you
are not going to get."
-
- Though the transition would be painful and the politics
treacherous, Berwick said it is possible to spend less on
medical care and have a healthier nation.
-
- "If we could just become La Crosse, think of how much
better off we would be," he said.
-
-
- Copyright 2009 Washington Post.
-
-
What to
know before buying supplements
-
- By The Associated Press
- Washington Post
- Tuesday, June 9, 2009
-
- -- The federal Food and Drug Administration does not
analyze the content of dietary supplements, which do not
need proof of safety or effectiveness before they go on
sale. Here are tips from the government on their use:
-
- -Don't self-diagnose a health condition or substitute a
supplement for medicine.
-
- -Ask your doctor before taking a supplement, especially
if you are pregnant, taking other medicines or are having
surgery soon.
-
- -Request proof from the manufacturer or distributor to
back up any claims.
-
- -Ask the seller or manufacturer for information on tests
showing safety or effectiveness of ingredients, and whether
consumers have complained of adverse events.
-
- -Look for "seals of approval" from independent groups
that have standards to help ensure the product was properly
made, contains what the label says, and is free of
contaminants. These groups include Consumerlab.com, NSF and
the U.S. Pharmacopeia.
-
- ---
- On the Net:
-
- Tips from FDA:http://www.fda.gov/Food/DietarySupplements/ConsumerInformation/ucm110567.htm
-
- ConsumerLab.com quality seal:http://www.consumerlab.com/seal.asp
-
- NSF certification:http://tinyurl.com/d3e3k7
-
- U.S. Pharmacopeia verification program:http://www.usp.org/USPVerified/dietarySupplements/
-
- © 2009 The Associated Press.
-
-
Tests show many supplements have quality problems
-
- Associated Press
- By Marilynn Marchione
- Washington Post
- Tuesday, June 9, 2009
-
- Lead in ginkgo pills. Arsenic in herbals. Bugs in a
baby's colic and teething syrup. Toxic metals and parasites
are part of nature, and all of these have been found in
"natural" products and dietary supplements in recent years.
-
- Set aside the issue of whether vitamin and herbal
supplements do any good.
-
- Are they safe? Is what's on the label really what's in
the bottle? Tests by researchers and private labs suggest
the answer sometimes is no.
-
- One quarter of supplements tested by an independent
company over the last decade have had some sort of problem.
Some contained contaminants. Others had contents that did
not match label claims. Some had ingredients that exceeded
safe limits. Some contained real drugs masquerading as
natural supplements.
-
- "We buy it just as the consumer buys it" from stores,
said Dr. Tod Cooperman, president of ConsumerLab.com. The
company tests pills for makers that want its seal of
approval, and publishes ratings for subscribers, much as
Consumer Reports does with household goods.
-
- Other tests, reported in scientific journals, found
prenatal vitamins lacking claimed amounts of iodine, and
supplements short on ginseng and hoodia - an African plant
sparking the latest diet craze.
-
- "There's at least 10 times more hoodia sold in this
country than made in the world, so people are not getting
hoodia," said Dr. Mehmet Oz, a heart surgeon and frequent
Oprah Winfrey guest who occasionally has touted the stuff.
-
- Industry groups say that quality problems are the
exception rather than the rule.
-
- "I believe that the problem is narrow, that the
well-established and reputable brands deserve their
reputations," said Michael McGuffin, president of the
American Herbal Products Association.
-
- Of course, prescription drugs have had problems, too.
Dozens of deaths were linked last year to tainted heparin, a
blood thinner produced in China, for example. However,
pharmaceutical drugs must show evidence to the government of
safety and effectiveness before they go on sale. Not so for
dietary supplements.
-
- Fifteen years ago, Congress passed a law that treats
supplements like food and allows them to go straight to
market without federal Food and Drug Administration
approval. The FDA can act only after consumers get sick or a
safety issue comes to light.
-
- "We called it 'the body rule,'" said William Obermeyer,
a chemist who left the FDA to found ConsumerLab.com with
Cooperman. If a supplement was harmful, "we had to have so
many adverse events before we could make a move on it. It
was really like closing the barn door after all the animals
left."
-
- The law said the FDA could write quality control rules
for products sold in the U.S. It took the FDA 13 years to
adopt these, and they are just now taking effect. But the
rules do not say what tests companies must do to prove what
is in their products, and some tests can be fooled by
subbing other ingredients. The rules also set no limits on
toxins such as lead; nor do they change the fundamental way
these products are sold to the public.
-
- "It leaves the level of quality up to the manufacturer,"
Cooperman said.
-
- In a written statement, FDA spokeswoman Susan Cruzan
said the new rules contain what is "needed to ensure
quality," and that products that contain contaminants or
whose labels do not honestly describe their contents, are
considered adulterated and subject to further action by the
agency. But she conceded that the agency is spread thin.
-
- "In that FDA has limited resources to analyze the
composition of food products, including dietary supplements,
it focuses these resources first on public health
emergencies and products that may have caused injury or
illness," she wrote.
-
- Millions of Americans take vitamin, herbal or other
dietary supplements. Annual sales exceed $23 billion, and
more than 40,000 products are on the market. Tens of
thousands of supplement-related health problems are handled
by U.S. poison control centers each year, according to a
report in the New England Journal of Medicine in 2002.
-
- Until last year, supplement makers were not required to
report problems to the FDA, and even now they must report
only serious ones. The agency estimates that more than
50,000 safety problems a year are related to supplement use.
-
- The Institute of Medicine, an independent science panel
that advises the government, studied the situation in 2005.
-
- "The committee is concerned about the quality of dietary
supplements in the United States. Product reliability is
low," says its report, which urged amending the 1994 law to
tighten consumer protections.
-
- Trade associations say the FDA's new rules do that.
-
- "We are FDA-regulated products," though not in the same
way as prescription or over-the-counter drugs, said Steven
Mister, president of the Council for Responsible Nutrition.
-
- The FDA can ask law enforcement to act against any
company selling an adulterated product, said McGuffin of the
herbal products association. "You can go to jail, you can
have your company seized," he said.
-
- "We represent companies that we consider the responsible
center of the industry," who are working to comply with the
new rules, he said.
-
- But his group only represents 250 of the 1,500 companies
selling such products. And even though millions of people
take supplements with no apparent ill effects, there have
been many quality problems that a consumer might never
realize because they don't always produce symptoms:
-
- -CONTAMINANTS
-
- ConsumerLab.com found lead in at least one brand each of
zinc, black cohosh and ginkgo products tested in recent
years. Lead can accumulate and cause many health problems,
and the testing company wants a national limit of 0.5
micrograms per day - a level that in California requires a
warning on the label.
-
- A fungal toxin was found in four red yeast rice products
in March 2008. And in 2007, federal officials warned about a
liquid herbal supplement sold for colic and teething pain
after finding cryptosporidium, a waterborne parasite that
causes severe diarrhea.
-
- Ayurvedics - popular herbals used in traditional
medicines from India - often contain hazardous metals,
studies in medical journals report. In 2004, researchers
tested 70 ayurvedic remedies in the Boston area and found
that one in five had potentially harmful levels of lead,
mercury or arsenic. Tests in Houston, Chicago, San Francisco
and New York City turned up similar results.
-
- Metals naturally accumulate in certain herbs and come
from the soil they are grown in. Many supplement ingredients
come from Europe, India and China.
-
- "We don't know how much of the ingredients are imported
- whether they're coming from across town or across the
world," Mister of the trade association conceded.
-
- But even manufacturers get duped, said Jana Hildreth of
the Analytical Research Collective, a group of scientists
advocating better supplement testing.
-
- "Companies started going to China and demanding lower
prices," and unscrupulous suppliers sometimes spiked
products with cheap ingredients that can trick lab tests,
she said. An example: a buckwheat derivative, rutin, in
place of pricier ginkgo.
-
- -POTENCY PROBLEMS
-
- In ConsumerLab.com testing last November, four out of
seven supplements contained less ginkgo than claimed on
their labels, and one failed to break apart properly to
release its ingredients. Seven out of nine failed in tests
in 2003, as did six out of 13 in 2005.
-
- "It is now believed that ginkgo is among the most
adulterated herbs," the company reports.
-
- Tests by California scientists of two dozen ginseng
supplements, reported in a nutrition journal in 2001, found
that many differed from their labels. The concentrations of
some ginseng compounds varied by up to 200-fold from product
to product.
-
- In ConsumerLab.com tests, six out of nine chondroitin
supplements failed testing in April 2007. One had only 8
percent of what it claimed to contain, and one "maximum
strength" product had none.
-
- Vitamins and minerals had problems, too. A "high
potency" iron supplement contained less than half the amount
claimed. Of 23 top-selling vitamin C pills, one provided
less than half the amount promised; the suggested dosages of
some others were beyond recommended safe levels. Of 10
vitamin A supplements, one provided twice its stated amount,
raising concern about toxic side effects.
-
- Last year, nearly 200 people were sickened by
supplements containing up to 200 times the amount of
selenium stated on the label. Symptoms included hair loss,
discolored and painful fingernails, muscle cramps, joint
pain, diarrhea and fatigue.
-
- -HIDDEN PRESCRIPTION DRUGS
-
- The FDA has repeatedly warned about herbal pills found
to contain versions of Viagra and similar drugs to help men
get an erection. These can pose a heart hazard, especially
when taken with certain medications.
-
- In December, the FDA expanded warnings about dozens of
brands of weight loss pills. Though the labels did not say
so, some contained sibutramine, a controlled substance that
poses heart risks; rimonabant, a drug not approved in the
United States; a seizure medicine, and a diuretic.
-
- Red yeast rice, a traditional Chinese medicine, has
compounds that may block cholesterol in a way similar to
statin drugs. Some red yeast rice products have been found
to contain lovastatin, the active ingredient in the drug
Mevacor. Problems can occur at high doses or with other
medicines.
-
- -OTHER RISKS
-
- Even "safe" supplements can be harmful. Beta-carotene
takers still had increased rates of lung cancer six years
after one study was stopped. These supplements "appear to
increase rates of the disease, particularly among smokers,"
the National Cancer Institute warns.
-
- In another study, men taking vitamin E were slightly
more likely to get prostate cancer, and those taking
selenium were a little more likely to develop diabetes. The
results could have been due to chance, but federal officials
were taking no chances and stopped the study last October.
-
- Other studies suggest that high doses of vitamin C may
help shield cancer cells from treatments designed to kill
the cancer.
-
- "Antioxidants are not the magic bullets that the
supplement industry would like consumers to believe," said
David Schardt, a nutrition expert with the consumer advocacy
group, the Center for Science in the Public Interest.
"They're not even necessarily benign."
-
- Herbal sex pills containing the African tree bark
extract yohimbe have landed men in hospitals with heart
rhythm problems. This herb can cause high blood pressure,
increased heart rate and other symptoms, the government
warns.
-
- The most serious side effects occurred with diet pills
containing ephedra - heart problems, seizures and even
deaths. The FDA banned it in 2004. The battle started in
1997, when the agency wanted strong warnings on labels, and
it became a test case of FDA authority that went all the way
to the U.S. Supreme Court, where the FDA ultimately
prevailed.
-
- -DRUG INTERACTIONS
-
- Ginkgo, vitamin K, garlic, ginseng and other herbals can
cause bleeding or clotting problems if taken with certain
medications or before surgery. St. John's wort, promoted for
depression, affects metabolism of more than half of all
prescription drugs and can undermine birth control pills.
Other supplements that can interfere with medicines include
glucosamine, saw palmetto, soy and valerian.
-
- -OVERSTATED HEALTH CLAIMS
-
- Makers can say a supplement addresses a nutrient
deficiency, supports health, or reduces the risk of
developing a problem, but then must say the product "is not
intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease."
-
- So consumers will see vague claims, such as "promotes
healthy immune system function." The immune system has
dozens of parts, and modifying one can be helpful or
harmful, so "it's a quack concept," said Dr. Stephen
Barrett, a retired physician who runs Quackwatch, a Web site
on medical scams.
-
- The Federal Trade Commission has stepped up actions
against deceptive ads, said commission lawyer Rich Cleland.
-
- "It is a little like playing Whack-A-Mole," because each
time one problem is resolved, more seem to pop up, he said.
-
- Last year, his agency reached a settlement against the
makers of Airborne, a supplement aimed at people in crowded
places such as airplanes, offices and schools. Company
founders "made false claims that Airborne products are
clinically proven to treat colds," and there is also no
evidence the products can prevent colds, the FTC complaint
says.
-
- Airborne's makers agreed to add $6.5 million to the
$23.5 million they had already agreed to pay to settle a
related private class-action lawsuit, bringing the total
settlement fund to $30 million.
-
- Industry also has stepped up self-policing. The Council
for Responsible Nutrition gave money to the Council of
Better Business Bureaus so it could hire a lawyer to
investigate some supplement sellers' sketchy claims.
-
- "There were cancer cures and 'blast off 29 pounds in 39
days' - really the Wild West of advertising. It was totally
out of control," said the BBB's advertising division
director, Andrea Levine.
-
- The BBB council targets the worst claims in popular
categories, such as diet, cold and flu, menopause, joint
problems and sleep aids.
-
- "We can't do them all," but want to send a broad signal
about what kinds of claims are over the line for each type
of product, she said.
-
- ---
- On the Net:
-
- FDA:
http://www.fda.gov/consumer/updates/supplements080408.html
-
- Government supplement advice:
http://tinyurl.com/alpr98
-
- and
http://tinyurl.com/kngv35
-
- © 2009 The Associated Press.
-
-
At Last, Facing Down Bullies (and Their Enablers)
-
- 18 and Under
-
- By Perri Klass, M.D.
- New York Times
- Tuesday, June 9, 2009
-
- Back in the 1990s, I did a physical on a boy in fifth or
sixth grade at a Boston public school. I asked him his
favorite subject: definitely science; he had won a prize in
a science fair, and was to go on and compete in a
multischool fair.
-
- The problem was, there were some kids at school who were
picking on him every day about winning the science fair; he
was getting teased and jostled and even, occasionally,
beaten up. His mother shook her head and wondered aloud
whether life would be easier if he just let the science fair
thing drop.
-
- Bullying elicits strong and highly personal reactions; I
remember my own sense of outrage and identification. Here
was a highly intelligent child, a lover of science, possibly
a future (fill in your favorite genius), tormented by
brutes. Here’s what I did for my patient: I advised his
mother to call the teacher and complain, and I encouraged
him to pursue his love of science.
-
- And here are three things I now know I should have done:
I didn’t tell the mother that bullying can be prevented, and
that it’s up to the school. I didn’t call the principal or
suggest that the mother do so. And I didn’t give even a
moment’s thought to the bullies, and what their lifetime
prognosis might be.
-
- In recent years, pediatricians and researchers in this
country have been giving bullies and their victims the
attention they have long deserved — and have long received
in Europe. We’ve gotten past the “kids will be kids” notion
that bullying is a normal part of childhood or the prelude
to a successful life strategy. Research has described
long-term risks — not just to victims, who may be more
likely than their peers to experience depression and
suicidal thoughts, but to the bullies themselves, who are
less likely to finish school or hold down a job.
-
- Next month, the American Academy of Pediatrics will
publish the new version of an official policy statement on
the pediatrician’s role in preventing youth violence. For
the first time, it will have a section on bullying —
including a recommendation that schools adopt a prevention
model developed by Dan Olweus, a research professor of
psychology at the University of Bergen, Norway, who first
began studying the phenomenon of school bullying in
Scandinavia in the 1970s. The programs, he said, “work at
the school level and the classroom level and at the
individual level; they combine preventive programs and
directly addressing children who are involved or identified
as bullies or victims or both.”
-
- Dr. Robert Sege, chief of ambulatory pediatrics at
Boston Medical Center and a lead author of the new policy
statement, says the Olweus approach focuses attention on the
largest group of children, the bystanders. “Olweus’s
genius,” he said, “is that he manages to turn the school
situation around so the other kids realize that the bully is
someone who has a problem managing his or her behavior, and
the victim is someone they can protect.”
-
- The other lead author, Dr. Joseph Wright, senior vice
president at Children’s National Medical Center in
Washington and the chairman of the pediatrics academy’s
committee on violence prevention, notes that a quarter of
all children report that they have been involved in
bullying, either as bullies or as victims. Protecting
children from intentional injury is a central task of
pediatricians, he said, and “bullying prevention is a subset
of that activity.”
-
- By definition, bullying involves repetition; a child is
repeatedly the target of taunts or physical attacks — or, in
the case of so-called indirect bullying (more common among
girls), rumors and social exclusion. For a successful
anti-bullying program, the school needs to survey the
children and find out the details — where it happens, when
it happens.
-
- Structural changes can address those vulnerable places —
the out-of-sight corner of the playground, the entrance
hallway at dismissal time.
-
- Then, Dr. Sege said, “activating the bystanders” means
changing the culture of the school; through class
discussions, parent meetings and consistent responses to
every incident, the school must put out the message that
bullying will not be tolerated.
-
- So what should I ask at a checkup? How’s school, who are
your friends, what do you usually do at recess? It’s
important to open the door, especially with children in the
most likely age groups, so that victims and bystanders won’t
be afraid to speak up. Parents of these children need to be
encouraged to demand that schools take action, and
pediatricians probably need to be ready to talk to the
principal. And we need to follow up with the children to
make sure the situation gets better, and to check in on
their emotional health and get them help if they need it.
-
- How about helping the bullies, who are, after all, also
pediatric patients? Some experts worry that schools simply
suspend or expel the offenders without paying attention to
helping them and their families learn to function in a
different way.
-
- “Zero-tolerance policies that school districts have are
basically pushing the debt forward,” Dr. Sege said. “We need
to be more sophisticated.”
-
- The way we understand bullying has changed, and it’s
probably going to change even more. (I haven’t even talked
about cyberbullying, for example.) But anyone working with
children needs to start from the idea that bullying has
long-term consequences and that it is preventable.
-
- I would still feel that same anger on my
science-fair-winning patient’s behalf, but I would now see
his problem as a pediatric issue — and I hope I would be
able to offer a little more help, and a little more
follow-up, appropriately based in scientific research.
-
- Copyright 2009 The New York Times Company.
-
-
Roche
Makes Headway on New Diabetes Drug
-
- By Anita Greil
- Wall Street Journal
- Tuesday, June 9, 2009
-
- ZURICH -- Roche Holding AG said Tuesday it is moving a
new potential blockbuster diabetes drug into late-stage
testing, paving the way for a possible launch in 2014.
-
- The drug belongs to a class of medicines called PPAR
agonists that has proved a big disappointment for many
pharmaceutical companies. GlaxoSmithKline PLC's Avandia
suffered a sharp drop in sales after it was tied to a
possible increase in the risk of heart problems. AstraZeneca
Plc terminated development of a similar drug called Galida
in 2006, and Bristol-Myers Squibb Co. halted development of
Pargluva in 2005, also citing safety concerns.
-
- Roche is hoping to avoid such problems by developing the
drug as something that can help diabetes patients who
already face a high risk of heart-attack or stroke.
-
- Roche estimates that in the U.S. and the three biggest
European countries there are around 500,000 diabetes
patients who suffered a heart attack, out of around 3
million people who suffer a heart attack each year.
-
- Roche's experimental medicine, called aleglitazar, was
shown to be as good as or better at lowering blood sugar and
certain blood fats in patients with type 2 diabetes as the
market leader Actos, made by Japan's Takeda Pharmaceutical
Co. There were no major unwanted side effects observed in
the study.
-
- Should the drug win regulatory approval, albeit unlikely
before 2015, it has the potential to eventually generate
annual sales of $1 billion or more.
-
- "The reason why so many drugs of this class have failed
is that you already have very good diabetes drugs out there,
which is creating high hurdles for new entrants," said Luke
Miels, Roche's head of strategic marketing for metabolic
diseases.
-
- First results from the late-stage study should be
available in 2013, which would allow for filing the drug for
regulatory approval in 2014, Mr. Miels said.
-
- Copyright 2009 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights
Reserved.
-
-
HIV rate among South African teens has dropped
-
- Associated Press
- By Clare Nullis
- Washington Post
- Tuesday, June 9, 2009
-
- CAPE TOWN, South Africa -- The number of new HIV
infections among South African teens has dropped
significantly, prompting hope that national efforts to
tackle the epidemic have finally turned a corner after years
of denial and delay.
-
- A report by the Human Sciences Research Council released
Tuesday said that although young people continue to have
multiple sexual partners - which drives South Africa's
epidemic - they are increasingly heeding advice to use a
condom.
-
- "There is clearly light at the end of the tunnel," said
Health Minister Dr Aaron Motsoaledi. "There is real light."
-
- Motsoaledi, a respected medical doctor, became health
minister last month. He must overcome the legacy of former
President Thabo Mbeki, who denied the link between HIV and
AIDS, and his health minister Manto Tshabalala-Msimang, who
mistrusted conventional anti-AIDS drugs and promoted
beetroot and lemon.
-
- "Unfortunately we spent a lot of time fighting each
other. I am quite sure that we are going to stop fighting
each other and start fighting the disease," said Motsoaledi.
"I am hoping that in the next few years the results will be
much more encouraging than this," he said.
-
- During nearly 10 years of neglect, new HIV infections
reached a peak of 1,000, with nearly 1,000 deaths from AIDS
every day. The council's report estimated that around 5.2
million South Africans were living with HIV last year - the
highest number of any country in the world.
-
- The report said that HIV prevalence in children between
2 and 14 fell from 5.6 percent in 2002 to 2.5 percent last
year, mainly thanks to the spread of drugs to prevent women
passing on the virus to their children.
-
- Young women continue to bear the brunt of the epidemic;
nearly one third of women aged 20 to 34 are infected with
the virus, the report said. Infection rates peak later in
men.
-
- The survey of more than 23,000 people was entitled "A
Turning Tide Among Teenagers?" In rare good news, it said
that HIV incidence - the number of new infections - among
teens was falling. For instance, incidence among
18-year-olds halved between 2005 and 2008 to 0.8 percent. In
20-year-olds it decreased from 2.2 percent to 1.7 percent.
-
- Olive Shisana, head of the research council and one of
the report's authors, said this was because of an increase
in condom use among young males aged between 15 and 24, from
57 percent in 2002 to 87 percent in 2008. In females of the
same age, there was also an increase of condom use, from 46
percent to 73 percent. Condom use among males aged 25 to 49
doubled and among women it tripled.
-
- "Young men have made a decision that they are going to
run around, but they are going to use a condom. They have
made a decision that they will have a lot of sex with a lot
of different people, but they are going ... to make sure
they are protected," she said.
-
- Every year the government distributes many millions of
condoms free of charge as part of its anti-AIDS campaign and
- to loud applause - health minister Motsoaledi indicated he
would be willing to increase the condom budget further.
-
- But on the downside, the survey showed that messages
that young people should abstain, delay their first sexual
encounter and have only one partner, were falling largely on
deaf ears. This was the approach traditionally promoted by
the U.S. President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief, which
is the biggest foreign donor of South Africa's anti-AIDS
drive.
-
- Funding from that plan paid for the survey, the third
conducted since 2002.
-
- It said the percentage of 15-59-year-old males who had
more than one partner in the past year increased from 9.4
percent in 2002 to 19.3 percent in 2008.
-
- It said there was an increase in the problem of teens
having older partners who would buy them food, clothes and
pay for transport. This is particularly risky because older
men have a higher HIV rate than teenage boys, and often the
teenage girls do not have the bargaining power to insist
that they wear a condom.
-
- Shisana said that in poor areas, girls came under
pressure from their families to stay in such relationships
despite the risk.
-
- Even more worryingly, the survey showed a decrease in
the proportion of people who understood about HIV prevention
from 66.4 percent in 2005 to 44.8 percent in 2008. More
people understood the need for condoms and the need to
dispel previously widespread myths that sex with babies
cured AIDS, but this was offset by a big increase in the
people who thought there was no risk in having multiple
partners.
-
- Motsoaledi said the government would try to strengthen
its AIDS prevention campaigns - long weakened because of
bureaucracy and mixed messages in the health department.
-
- "It is clear our work is well cut. We can't pretend that
we don't know what to do," he said.
-
- © 2009 The Associated Press.
-
-
Is This a
Pandemic? Define ‘Pandemic’
-
- The Doctor’s World
-
- By Lawrence K. Altman, M.D.
- Washington Post
- Tuesday, June 9, 2009
-
- After decades of warnings about the inevitability of
another pandemic of influenza, it is astonishing that health
officials have failed to make clear to the public, even to
many colleagues, what they mean by the word pandemic.
-
- Generations of people have used the term to describe
widespread epidemics of influenza, cholera and other
diseases. But as the new H1N1 swine influenza virus spreads
from continent to continent, it is clear that a useful
definition is far more complicated and elusive than
officials had thought.
-
- And what is at stake is far more than an exercise in
semantics. A clear understanding of the term is central to
the World Health Organization’s six-level staging system for
declaring a pandemic, which in turn informs countries when
to set their control efforts in motion.
-
- Dictionaries and medical journals offer little guidance.
Their definitions can be too vague or too narrow,
contradictory and clouded by jargon.
-
- “There is a lot of misinformation in the medical
literature, and it is really quite hard to figure out what
is and what is not a pandemic,” said Dr. David M. Morens, an
epidemiologist at the National Institute of Allergy and
Infectious Diseases who has been studying the history of
pandemics.
-
- The word implies the rapid spread of an infectious
disease to many countries in different regions, hitting each
with more or less the same severity. But in fact, severity
varies — not all people are infected at the same time, and
not every country need be affected.
-
- And there can be many other factors, including the
numbers and percentages of people falling ill and dying; a
population’s vulnerability to the disease, based on previous
rates of infection; and the quality of health care
facilities and disease monitoring systems.
-
- Not least is that scientists do not know precisely how
pandemics arise, what fuels them, why they vary in their
lethality, why some occur in waves and why they stop.
-
- Health officials have long preached that with influenza,
the only sure bet is to expect the unexpected. The new swine
influenza virus, which appeared suddenly after years of
warning about a potential pandemic of avian influenza, upset
the W.H.O.’s assumptions that most people have the same
understanding of the word pandemic.
-
- For years, the organization’s Web site defined an
influenza pandemic as causing “enormous numbers of deaths
and illness.” But the agency recently pulled the definition,
apologizing for causing confusion and anxiety.
-
- One of the biggest problems in public health is
communicating risk assessment.
-
- United States and W.H.O. officials say their
preparedness plans are intended for governments, not people
in the street. Officials bristle at criticism that their
messages and plans have led the public to equate the word
pandemic with the Spanish influenza of 1918-19, the worst
recorded pandemic in history, killing 20 million to 100
million people.
-
- In preparing for the worst, officials have considered
milder pandemics, said Dr. Nancy J. Cox, chief of the
influenza division at the Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention in Atlanta.
-
- But Dr. William Schaffner, the chairman of preventive
medicine at Vanderbilt University, said that “we, the public
health community, deserve to be chided” about the confusion.
-
- “We ought to be able to do a better job in communicating
in an understandable way,” he said in an interview.
-
- Scientists like to assert that theirs is an exact
discipline. But like the terms “evidence -based medicine”
and “peer review,” pandemic turns out to be another example
of imprecise vocabulary that doctors use every day, assuming
everyone understands their meaning.
-
- Journals, textbooks and reference works use pandemic in
discussing certain diseases, but rarely define the word.
-
- For example, the definition section of the Control of
Communicable Diseases Manual, a standard reference work,
includes “endemic” (said of a disease that is usually
present in an area or a population group) and “epidemic”
(more cases of an illness than would normally be expected)
but not “pandemic.”
-
- The disease manual’s editor, Dr. David L. Heymann, a
retired assistant director-general of the W.H.O., said the
term had not caused confusion in the past, but assured me in
an interview that “pandemic will be defined in the next
edition.”
-
- Even the indexes of most major medical textbooks do not
list pandemic. One is Harrison’s Principles of Internal
Medicine, of which Dr. Anthony S. Fauci, who directs the
National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, is a
main editor.
-
- “It’s a mistake, and I’m surprised it’s not there
because it should have been,” Dr. Fauci said in an
interview.
-
- Government agencies do not have official lists of
pandemics. Textbooks cite many recent and old ones,
including these:
-
- ¶AIDS. Many experts have called H.I.V. a pandemic.
Others disagree, saying the virus is pandemic only in
Africa.
-
- ¶Cholera. Since 1817, most experts agree, the world has
had seven pandemics of this bacterial illness, which causes
severe diarrhea and dehydration. ¶Acute hemorrhagic
conjunctivitis. Beginning in 1969, an enterovirus has caused
tens of millions of cases of a highly contagious, acute,
painful, but rarely blinding, form of hemorrhagic eye
inflammation.
-
- ¶Dengue. Since World War II, this mosquito-borne viral
disease has spread widely in Asia and Latin America.
-
- ¶Syphilis. A pandemic of the bacterial disease raced
through Europe and Asia after Columbus’s return from America
and during mass movements of armies in Europe.
-
- Although pandemics have been classically limited to
infectious diseases, the term has spread to noninfectious,
chronic ones. For example, many health officials now speak
of pandemics of obesity and heart disease.
-
- Knowledge about past pandemics is necessarily
incomplete; historical accounts cannot make up for the
absence of modern disease monitoring and laboratory tests.
-
- About 14 pandemics of influenza have been described
since the 16th century, with the first indisputable one
occurring in 1889.
-
- In 1580, an influenza pandemic swept through Asia into
Europe within six weeks, and at least 10 percent of Rome’s
81,000 residents died in the first week, said Dr. Michael T.
Osterholm, director of the Center for Infectious Disease
Research and Policy at the University of Minnesota. Some
Spanish cities were almost totally depopulated.
-
- Dr. Morens, of the infectious diseases institute, said
his studies of influenza pandemics left a confusing track
record and “are rewiring our brains about thinking about
influenza.”
-
- “The medical literature will tell you there were three
pandemics in the 1830s,” he said — “one from 1830 to 1832, a
second in 1833 to 1834 and a third in 1836 to 1837. But I am
beginning to think they were all one pandemic.”
-
- Dr. Morens said he was puzzled as to why no influenza
pandemics were recorded for nearly 150 years after the one
in 1580, although there were some severe localized
epidemics.
-
- “A period of pandemic stability makes us wonder whether
a pandemic comes at any time by chance,” he said, “or
whether something about epidemic situations prevents
pandemics,” or at least delays them.
-
- The W.H.O.’s staging system has long been part of its
plan for an influenza pandemic. Deep concern about a
potential pandemic of the H5N1 avian influenza virus led the
organization to convene a large meeting of experts in 2005.
Among other things, the experts recommended simplifying the
staging system.
-
- A number of doctors ask why health agencies do not
declare seasonal influenza a pandemic when it spreads around
the world.
-
- But Dr. Osterholm, the Minnesota expert, said that “you
can’t use the terminology for just worldwide transmission,
because if you did that, you would say every seasonal flu
year is a pandemic.”
-
- “To me,” he continued, “a pandemic is basically a new or
novel agent emerging with worldwide transmission.”
-
- Dr. Keiji Fukuda, an influenza expert who is an
assistant director-general at the W.H.O., said in an
interview that “as difficult as things are right now,” the
problem of defining a pandemic and communicating risk “would
be magnitudes worse and more confusing” if the agency had
not dealt with AIDS, SARS and avian influenza.
-
- Those experiences prompted new international health
regulations and pandemic plans, and allowed critical
scientific information to be disseminated quickly, he said.
-
- The process was “painful, sure,” he said. “But you can’t
really do anything like this without having some amount of
pain.”
-
- Copyright 2009 The New York Times Company.
-
-
Navy reports 21 swine flu cases on USS Iwo Jima
-
- Associated Press
- Salisbury Daily Times
- Tuesday, June 9, 2009
-
- NORFOLK, Va. (AP) — The Navy is reporting 21 cases of
swine flu onboard the USS Iwo Jima.
-
- Navy spokesman Cmd. Cappy Surette says the Centers for
Disease Control and and Prevention confirmed the first case
on May 27. The amphibious assault ship left New York on May
26 after participating in Fleet Week.
-
- Surette says the cases were mild. All 21 sailors and
Marines were treated in New York and have since returned to
duty.
-
- Several other people have been isolated in the ship's
medical ward after developing flu-like symptoms.
-
- The Iwo Jima is scheduled to return to Norfolk later
this week.
-
- Surette says the Navy has had 147 confirmed cases of
H1N1, and 137 of those people have returned to work.
-
- Copyright 2009 The Associated Press. All rights
reserved.
-
-
Egypt: Five more Americans test positive for swine flu
-
- Associated Press
- USA Today
- Tuesday, June 9, 2009
-
- CAIRO (AP) — Another four students and a faculty member
at the American University in Cairo have contracted swine
flu, said Egypt's health minister, bringing the total number
of those infected at the school to seven.
-
- The five cases were discovered when tests were carried
out at a dormitory after two students from the United States
were diagnosed with swine flu, Hatem el-Gabali told
reporters Tuesday. He did not disclose the nationalities of
the five new cases.
-
- AUC Communications Manager, Doaa Farag confirmed that
the five new cases are all Americans, and consist of four
students and a faculty member.
-
- The dorm, which the ministry said houses 234 people
including 110 students from 10 different countries, is under
quarantine for seven days. AUC officials said Tuesday they
were waiting for confirmation of the test results.
-
- The Health Ministry said the rest of the dorm dwellers
tested negative, but the dormitory will remain under
quarantine.
-
- Every year hundreds of foreign students take classes at
AUC, which has a 5,500 person student body, 81% of whom are
Egyptians.
-
- The dormitory is located in Zamalek, an upper class
neighborhood of Cairo and home to many foreigners and
embassies. The university itself recently relocated to the
desert outskirts of the capital.
-
- The two swine flu cases were discovered Sunday night
after the students exhibited flu-like symptoms and tested
positive for the virus. El-Gabali said Monday that they were
recovering and would be released from the hospital in 48
hours.
-
- The 23-year-old students who contracted the flu, a male
from New Jersey and a female from Florida, arrived from the
United States on May 28 for a summer program at the
university, but did not exhibit symptoms until Friday.
-
- Travelers arriving in Egypt are photographed, their body
temperature scanned and addresses taken down in case follow
up is necessary.
-
- Egypt's government has come under criticism from
international animal rights groups for its decision to
slaughter the nation's 300,000 pigs in response to the swine
flu problem.
-
- Copyright 2009 The Associated Press. All rights
reserved.
-
-
WHO may soon raise swine flu alert to pandemic level
-
- Associated Press
- USA Today
- Tuesday, June 9, 2009
-
- GENEVA (AP) — The World Health Organization said Tuesday
a spike in swine flu cases in Australia may push it to
finally announce the first flu pandemic in 41 years. It also
expressed concern about an unusual rise in severe illness
from the disease in Canada.
-
- WHO's flu chief Keiji Fukuda said the agency wanted to
avoid "adverse effects" if it announces a global outbreak of
swine flu. Fukuda said people might panic or that
governments might take inappropriate actions if WHO declares
a pandemic.
-
- Some flu experts think the world already is in a
pandemic and that WHO has caved in to country requests that
a declaration be postponed.
-
- "On the surface of it, I think we are in phase 6," or a
pandemic, said Margaret Chan, WHO's director-general.
-
- Chan said it was important to verify the reports that
the virus is becoming established outside North America
before declaring a pandemic. "The decision to make a phase 6
announcement is a heavy responsibility, a responsibility
that I will take very seriously, and I need to be convinced
that I have indisputable evidence," she said.
-
- Chan said she will hold a conference call with
governments Wednesday in order to verify some of the reports
she has received before making a formal announcement. "Once
I get indisputable evidence, I will make the announcement,"
she told reporters in Geneva.
-
- WHO said the virus has infected 26,563 people in 73
countries and caused 140 deaths. Most of the cases have been
in North America, but Australia also has seen a sharp
increase in recent days.
-
- In most of the 73 countries, the new H1N1 virus has
triggered only mild illness. But the fact that some of the
deaths have occurred in otherwise healthy adults has
prompted WHO to classify the outbreak as "moderate" for the
time being.
-
- "Approximately half the people who have died from this
H1N1 infection have been previously healthy people," Fukuda
said, adding that this was "one of the observations which
has given us the most concern."
-
- Wealthy countries such as the U.S., Canada and Britain
already have large stockpiles of antivirals used to treat
swine flu, but many developing countries have no supplies of
the drugs and could be more vulnerable to the virus, given
their struggle with widespread problems such as AIDS,
malnutrition and malaria.
-
- Some pharmaceutical companies are preparing to make a
swine flu vaccine, if WHO declares a pandemic.
-
- The number of cases in Australia jumped to more than
1,000 by Monday, with the vast majority reported from the
southern state of Victoria.
-
- If the swine flu virus were to be shown to be spreading
rapidly from person to person in another world region beyond
North America, such as Australia or Europe, that should
trigger the conditions for WHO to declare a pandemic,
meaning the outbreak has gone global.
-
- "We are getting really very close to knowing that we are
in a pandemic situation," Fukuda said.
-
- He also said it was more important that countries take
"the right actions" than that they accurately report the
extent of their outbreaks.
-
- With 675 reported swine flu cases in Britain, some
experts suspect the virus already is entrenched in
communities, but that U.K. health authorities are
deliberately not testing for the virus and not reporting
cases.
-
- In recent weeks, two Greek students caught swine flu in
Scotland — who had no history of contact with any confirmed
cases, a clear sign the virus is spreading in British
communities.
-
- "Our primary concern is not so much the numbers that are
being reported," Fukuda said. He said countries simply
needed to take appropriate actions to handle their
outbreaks.
-
- In his weekly update on the outbreak, Fukuda also
addressed reports that an unusually large number of severe
cases have occurred among Canada's Inuit population.
-
- "There are reports of infections occurring in Inuit
communities with a disproportionate number of serious
cases," he said. "These are observations of concern to us."
-
- Copyright 2009 The Associated Press. All rights
reserved.
-
- Opinion
- ---
-
BACK TO TOP
|
-
|
-
|